Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

Time For A Change In The Rules

Time For A Change In The Rules

I don't know if any of you guys and gals have noticed a massive flaw in cup competitions featuring the away goals rule?

It first crossed my mind a couple of seasons when we were eliminated from the Carling cup in the very same stage of the competition our young guns are attempting to navigate this evening.

After a 1-0 defeat at the JJB courtesy of a header from life long Gooner Paul Scharner, Mr Wenger fielded a rather strong side at Highbury, giving a rare league cup start to a certain Thierry Henry.

The afforementioned captain duly nodded home a header in the first half after some neat play by English, yes that's English right back Kerrea Gilbert.

With normal time over and both teams having scored one goal and kept a clean sheet, extra time beckoned. In the second half of extra time Robin van Persie smashed home one of the best free-kicks you're ever likely to see in front of a joyous North Bank, and it appeared Arsenal's route to the final had been secured.

However with seconds remaining, Jason Roberts had other idea's. The big centre forward slotting home and sending the rapturous Wiganers on a rare trip to a cup final on the away goals rule.

Many fans prefer to play the first leg of a two legged tie away from home, offering that knowing exactly what you need to do in your home leg as a distinct advantage, but that is just a matter of opinion.

The fact is that playing away from home in the second leg holds an actual, statistical advantage. When a team plays the first leg away from home, the maximum amount of playing time afforded to score an away goal is 90 minutes plus injury time. That's it, once the final whistle blows there are no more chances. However, should the second leg finish with the exact same scoreline as the first (with the away team having already completed the same 90 minutes away from home as their opponents) the away side are then given an additional 30 minutes in which to bag an away goal, leaving the home side whatever time remains to score 2.

Seems unfair, no?

If the draws for the semi finals were made with the teams seeded then the competition's officials may be able to explain this one away, but they aren't, the draws are made completely at random.

Arsenal may benefit from this massive oversight over the course of our two legged semi-final with arch rivals Totteringham Hotspur, but that doesn't make it right.

And yes......I am bored today :)

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Join the Vital Fantasy Football League - its Free!

Date:Wednesday January 9 2008
Time: 11:10AM


Lol Rocky you seem very very bored. Although you make a valid point, there is no perfectly fair system. We cannot have one or two more matches extra just for that. I say just get on with it and play the half hour.
09/01/2008 11:20:00
The away goals rule should stand the 180 minutes of home and away football, in the event of a tie the extra time should effectively become a whole new game with no advantage offered to either team. It's the only way to keep the process completely fair.
09/01/2008 11:23:00
With the players playing 40-50 games a season it will become exhausting don't you think? I don't think the half hour provides a very big advantage to either of the two teams. Just get on with it and finish the game is what I have to say!
09/01/2008 11:26:00
What will become exhausting? They will still be playing the 30 minutes injury time that they would be playing anyway, but with no away goals rule. If that remains a tie, then penalties it is.
09/01/2008 11:29:00
Misread your quote. I thought you said instead of an extra-time we should play an entire game of 90 minutes without any advantage. Agree with what you said here though that the extra 30 minutes should be played without the away goals rule.
09/01/2008 11:33:00
I know it's just a small part of the game and people may think I'm being a little petty scrutinising it this much, but fair play all across the board is the only way to go.
09/01/2008 11:36:00
I know it wouldn't hurt to change that rule? But would the law makers go for it after years an years playing the same way? I doubt it.
09/01/2008 11:37:00
I accept the logic of your argument Rocky. It makes sense to me. But I guess the away team having to take penalties in front of a partisan crowd might feel that they are similarly disadvantaged. That's the problem with all knockout tournaments. However you construct it the draw always favours one team or another. Cup games are as much about good fortune as good ability.
09/01/2008 11:42:00
On the face of it, it appears to be a reasonable argument. However on closer inspection it is a perfectly fair system, and I say this for the following reason. While you are correct about the away goal rule, you neglect to mention in your argument the benefit of playing an extra 30 minutes with home advantage. IMO one cancels out the other, and is about as fair as you are going to get
09/01/2008 11:49:00
it's a crock of ****. you either have the away goal rule or you don't. imagine this scenario; last night's game at stamford bridge finished 1-1, then the game in a fortnight finishes 0-0. that means it goes to extra time, but if no more goals are scored in extra time, and thus everton win. what's the point of having the extra 30 mins then? how come the rules are different in this cup to any other cup? anyone know?
09/01/2008 11:50:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Arsenal Articles

Arsenal Begin Onyekuru Talks?

Arsenal could now be in the 'driving seat' to secure Onyekuru, linked with Everton, Southampton and West Brom last week, who has a £6.8m release clause in his Eupen contract.

We Can Bounce Back Like Chelsea - Cech

It goes without saying Arsenal would have preferred Champions League football next season but Petr Cech feels the Gunners can come back stronger, like Chelsea have this season.

Cech Plays Down 2016/17 Disappointment

Goalkeeper Petr Cech has tried to be philosophical when it comes to Arsenal missing out on Champions League football in the season of 2017/18.

Wembley Doubts For Defensive Duo

Manager Arsene Wenger has already ruled out Laurent Koscielny from the FA Cup Final against Chelsea later this month but Gabriel is also a doubt.

Archived Vital Arsenal Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Arsenal
Write For Vital Arsenal
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

Everton MotM
Suggested By:
Sub - Mertesacker0%
Sub - Coquelin0%
Sub - Iwobi0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Chelsea 38 30 3 5 93 52
2 Spurs 38 26 8 4 86 60
3 Man City 38 23 9 6 78 41
4 Liverpool 38 22 10 6 76 36
5 Arsenal 38 23 6 9 75 33
6 Man Utd 38 18 15 5 69 25
7 Everton 38 17 10 11 61 18
8 Southampton 38 12 10 16 46 -7
9 AFC Bournemouth 38 12 10 16 46 -12
10 WBA 38 12 9 17 45 -8
11 West Ham 38 12 9 17 45 -17
12 Leicester City 38 12 8 18 44 -15
13 Stoke 38 11 11 16 44 -15
14 Crystal Palace 38 12 5 21 41 -13
15 Swansea 38 12 5 21 41 -25
16 Burnley 38 11 7 20 40 -16
17 Watford 38 11 7 20 40 -28
R Hull City 38 9 7 22 34 -43
R Middlesbrough 38 5 13 20 28 -26
R Sunderland 38 6 6 26 24 -40
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Arsenal Fixtures (view all)

May 27 2017 5:30PM : Chelsea (H)
FA Cup

Vital Members League Table

The Vital Football Members League