UK time is: 09:56:58
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Scream To A Sigh

Over night the news of William Gallas' punishment spread through the media with the speed of a late night locomotive, the captain had not travelled to Eastlands and was unlikely to play. We arrived at a blustery cold City of Manchester Stadium, winters claws well and truly entrenched on rosy cheeks. Both sets of supporters came into the stadium with their respective teams in something of a slump, City had one point from four games whilst a jet black cloud hung over Arsenal which threatened to jettison its season into mediocrity. Questions abound from the captain as to his teams hunger for the fight (please don't fall into the media beartrap of believing he accused his teammates, he accused himself as well), we wanted a response, somebody to stand up and prove their captain wrong. The lack of confidence resonating around both clubs was genuflected in the stands, where both sets of supporters were pensive and quiet. The congeniality usually apparent between the supporters in this fixture was not quite apparent, the bonhomie broken completely when the home fans tunefully enquired 'where's your captain gone?'

We were promised an open, attacking game of balletic beauty. What we had was an ugly stalemate, Arsenal passed the ball in their slow, ineffective, deliberate way with not enough urgency and conviciton to break City's light blue wall of resistance. City occasionally broke away on the counter attack, but usually delivered an amaeteurishly awful final ball. It took 30 minutes for any semblance of an opportunity to be created, Vassell attacked Clichy down Arsenal's left, delivered a low cross which Benjani could only slide narrowly wide. Five minutes later, Arsenal responded by working the goalkeeper for the first time. van Persie won a free kick thirty yards from goal, Nasri curled it towards the bottom corner, Joe Hart beat it out, Bendtner was alert and alive to reach the rebound, cleverly backheeling it to Alex Song, who screwed the ball wide from an obscure angle. Once again, City attacked Arsenal's left virtually unchallenged, Wright Phillips flighted in a cross unchallenged and Benjani headed wide with scarcely a challenge.

The game seemed to be drifting towards a moribund stalemate until Arsenal made their customary defensive error. It began and ended with weak clearances from Clichy, his first, half way inside his own half, reached Wright Phillips. Benjani and Ireland powered forwards as Denilson and Song ambled back half heartedly, Benjani nudged the ball to Ireland on the edge of the area, Djourou's challenge was far too polite and lacking in authority, but the ball broke to Clichy with Silvestre's momentum taking him towards his left back, once again Clichy was too timid causing him to screw the clearance into the path of Irleand who lifted the ball over Almunia. The goal was an absolute shambles, from Song and Denilson's awful attempts to trudge back, to Clichy's effemenate attempts to clear the ball. At the other end of the pitch, Richard Dunne was a towering presence, with a display of committed no nonsense defending. Had he been in Clichy's position he would have cleared his lines, clattered Silvestre and apologised later. It was a goal paradigmatic of our problems, no authority, no responsibility, a collection of individuals who do not trust one another, do not work for one another and by all accounts, don't even like one another very much. If Arsene is looking for a new captain, he might look at Robin van Persie, who epitomises everything about Arsenal at the moment. Ridiculously talented, naturally able, gifted with a football. But his work rate off the ball is appalling, his only interest in the game is when the ball is at his feet, other than that he has no interest in supporting his midfield or his strike partner. In short, van Persie, like Arsenal, has the feet of a world class footballer, but the brain and mentality of a small child.

It was a half made frustrating by our problems being laid bare for all to see, the players just did not work for one another. On the very few occasions Bendtner actually won anything upfront, Diaby or van Persie were rocking back on their heels, not anticipating the ball, not trusting their team mate to win it. There was an occasion at the beginning of the half, when Arsenal actually looked hungry, van Persie fended off three City players excellently with his back to goal, he laid the ball off to Diaby, who was not concentrating, not on his toes and not trusting van Persie to make the pass. The symbiosis in this side is non existent, it's an assorted rabble of egos. But the Gunners began the second half with a flurry of activity, they seemed to realise that the passing game does not work in front of packed defences in less you activate it at a rate of more than one pass every ten seconds. Diaby wormed himself free in the box from Bendtner's pay off, but blasted the ball over from a narrow angle. Nasri and Clichy combined with quick, effusive passes, Clichy delivered a sumptuous left wing cross which Bendtner narrowly missed amidst the suspicion that he was pulled back by Micah Richards down in front of us high in the North Stand Upper Tier. Nasri got at the City defence and won a free kick on the edge of the area. The free kick was positioned for a right footer, Nasri had delivered a decent effort in the first half with van Persie off being treated. But you can ask Wesley Sneijder the sort of childish reaction you can expect from van Persie if you dare take a set piece off him, with the angle against his left foot, van Persie curled the free kick into the side netting. All for one and one for all.

Two minutes later, van Persie was muscled off the ball by Wright Phillips, Denilson and Song were once again sadly absent in the midfield, leaving the young Gavin Hoyte unprotected, unsure whether to go to Wright Phillips who careered forwards with the ball, or stay with the runner Robinho. In the end he could do neither as Wright Phillips released Robinho, and the Brazilian impudently and beautifully lobbed the ball over Almunia. Once again the midfield were nowhere to be seen in protecting an unfamiliar defence. Having now seen the goal back on the highlights, I couldn't see Song or Denilson enter the frame of the screen once during that move. Gallas had said his team lack the hunger for the fight, that assertion did not appear to hurt or trouble the players as they spent the remainder of the game proving him right. Shoulders were firmly slumped and the cry of surrender was painted onto every player's shirt, with the exception of Clichy and substitute Ramsey, the rest may as well have been carrying little white flags. A theme not lost on the home fans who chanted, 'Gallas was right, you're soft as shite.' There are times in football grounds when you simply cannot muster a response to your taunters. It's usually because you agree with them.

Arsenal were in freefall, Wright Phillips hit the cross to the backpost, Vassell shot at goal, Almunia beat the ball out for Robinho to flick the rebound in. The linesman's flag rescued our blushes, it would prove to be a bagatelle gesture, but appreciated all the same. On further inspection, Clichy was playing Robinho onside. The officials were taking pity on us. Once again, Arsenal were all at sea at the back, playing an impossibly high line at the back as Kompany slipped Robinho through on goal. His natural showmanship got the better of him as he needlessly rounded Almunia, allowing Djourou to power back and clear off the line. At least somebody was trying. With five minutes left, van Persie attempted the now oft tried trick of robbing the keeper of the ball as he attempts to kick out. This is now against the rules, it was codified in the wake of Henry's attempts when there was no rule surrounding the keeper kicking the ball out of his hands. Henry was aware of a loophole in the rules and tried to exploit it, van Persie needed Alan Wiley to explain that this act now qualifies as ungentlemanly conduct. Still, it's an improvement on barging the keeper out of the way and getting yourself sent off. An incident in the 88th minute summed up our apathy. Ramsey, who was such a refreshing entry into the game, someone who was alert and alive, someone looking to fight for a place in the side (not many of our players currently have to do that). Ramsey won a free kick thirty yards out, showing alertness, he spotted Bendtner in space on the edge of the area and played the ball to him quickly, Bendtner was not concentrating, not interested and was not prepared to receive. He promptly lost it.

As the travelling support spent the last ten minutes outvoicing their hosts, who were assured victory, City wetn up the other end and Djourou was harshly ajudged to have felled Sturridge in the area. Peculiarly the screens in the stadium replayed the incident, Sturridge tucked the spot kick away to the tune of the Arsenal faithful still singing, trying to guilt their team into a token effort. There were no boos at the final whistle, people simply walked out. Emirates dwellers take note, a player turning to acknowledge support will have far more to think about by looking at 3,000 backs turning to the exit than a load of spoiled children booing like morons. That just vindicates the players in their own minds. After the game the same old whipping boys were assigned blame on the coach, the names Denilson and Bendtner rubbished ad nauseam. Both had horrible games, but after a good ten minutes of this frustrated chatter I had to ask those around me why I had not heard the name van Persie uttered even once. 'Oh, sure, he had a bad game too.' It exemplifies a problem with Arsenal fans that confuses and frustrates me no end. Supporters seem to arrive at games with pre conceived opinions, 'I don't like Bendtner/ Denilson/ Song/ Eboue, the second it all goes wrong I will vent my fury at them.' Meanwhile, the golden children, van Persie, Walcott, Toure, are never implicated. The lack of objectivity and proportion staggers me. Why can't people watch a game and make assumptions based on what happened rather than exorcising their likes and dislikes? van Persie was awful, Denilson was terrible, Song was laughable, Bendtner was amateur. Implicate all of them rather than just those you don't like. Meanwhile, Silvestre actually had an alright game, but was afforded no credit simply because people don't like him.

There is something liberating about this defeat in a way, the manager cannot conceal the cracks any longer, the myopia cannot continue. Gallas was 100% wrong to say what he did, but every one of his assertions was 100% correct, he just should not have verbalised them publicly. The pride of the players should have been hurt and pricked a response from them. It didn't. We are all but told publicly that van Persie has an attitude problem and he insults his team mates, so he responds by exacerbating it further. We are told the players lack the desire for the fight, so Song, Bendtner and Denilson amble around the pitch feeling sorry for themselves the instant we go 2-0 down. Gallas alleges we lack maturity, so the manager throws the raw Gavin Hoyte into an underperforming and unfamiliar backline against Robinho. The Premier League has changed now, Chelsea changed it by packing their team with players like Essien, Drogba and Ballack, powerful, forceful players who are precise and direct when they pass the ball. United responded to the sea change, Ferguson has no compunction about playing water carriers, workhorses like Fletcher and Park, to feed the physically impressive Rooney, Ronaldo and Tevez, players who bulldoze the opposition when they pass the ball. Wenger has packed his side with lightweight artistes, on the few occasions we do actually win a tackle in midfield, we pass the ball slowly, deliberately. Without the directness of Rosicky and the ability to dribble through packed defences of Hleb, we are easy to play against. Get numbers back and our contemplative, slow passing is easy to enervate. The passing game only works when it is executed quickly and with conviction, our players do not trust one another enough to manifest this and they won't work for one another enough to win the ball back when we do lose it in the manner Fletcher or Park would. Bereft of Adebayor and Fabregas we completely and utterly lack this commodity going forward and we don't have it anywhere in the squad at all in midfield. The sad thing is, I wasn't particularly angry after the game or on the journey home, in truth, ever since September 2nd, this is exactly what I expected.LD.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Tim Stillman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday November 23 2008

Time: 12:45PM

Your Comments

Good read as always LD. I can even sense the muted disappointment. As for 'the myopia cannot continue', in light of AW's assertion that we controlled the game, i would not bet on it?
Gael-Force
On the bright side, there is only one way from here: UP. It surely can't get worse... We have won nothing for 4 years and yet we aren't hungry. Overpaid footballers i think. Maybe as said in the article, Ferguson's approach of workhorses and 4/5 30m superstar players works best than our team artistes in the short term. The long term might favour us? Just trying to lighten up...
Gael-Force
I would have gone with 'From despair to where?'...I don't think we started the game that badly and controlled most of the first half..I always feel that as long as we don't concede we are always likely to win, however, once we do concede, our naivety means we're always likely to be caught on the break...in that sense, surely the manager was right...
Anon 1
Its a shame that we have players who are in fans bad books before judging their performances and it a shame that we have our favourites...
Tom14
It will be very interesting to see who writes the captain's programme notes on Tuesday night. Anon, I actually typed that headline out first time around, but I realised I'd already used it last season. The manager has proved time and again he can find quality players without spending astronomical sums, he needs to summon those powers again in January.
Little Dutch
Lets hope you won't need to sink to those depths anymore..to be honest I think 'Scream to a Sigh' sums up the weary resignation I felt by the end of the game...we need to remember that the team we fielded was not a first choice eleven and we are simply a few additions away from greatness.. though herein lies the frustration..people can speak about missing Flamini but the importance of Hleb continues to be underestimated..
Anon 1
If Chelsea makes a bid for Van Persie, is there a chance of it being accepted?
k_chelski
For me the frustrating thing's that RvP did show a much better attitude when he came back from injury early last season. That's when the whole team played well, mind. He kept saying how his long-term lay-off made him come back stronger, more mature, etc. That's why I'm particularly disappointed with him. OTherwise after the first 30 mins or so and until Ramsey came on, we had no quality or urgency to speak of. I started screaming for Arsene to sub Diaby with him towards the end of the 1st half. And now if I have to painstakingly find a positive from the game, yes, it was Ramsey. Only he, Djourou, Hoyte and Silvestre showed any sign of the right attitude.
GoonerLou
The Boss will sort it out in january, but that is still a long way away. we can't afford to drop anymore points now. we've picked up 11 points from the last 9 league games which is pathetic. this surely cannot continue any longer. i dun see a leader in this team besides Gallas. if he is stripped of it, then surely we need to bring in a leader in January. i hope Arsene will atleast consider bringing Patrick back, cuz i really can't think of anyone else who can turn this around..
luckys_10
My heart sank when I saw the starting XI. There comes a time when Wenger must be true to his word and play some of the young players that he didn't want to stifle with big signings. I hesitate to use the phrase 'big signings' because Arsenal don't need big names, they simply need a few astute signings in the right positions. Part of me wonders whether Flamini would welcome a return to Arsenal with a guaranteed starting place assured. The profligacy in front of goal should hopefully be addressed by Eduardo's return. I concur with your admiration for Man Utd's style and approach which I have always regarded as the best the Premiership has to offer. They are efficient, effective and never embellish their play until a solid lead is established. Arsenal have become a sad caricature of how they played in the early part of the decade and I don't see this improving. This must be how Liverpool fans felt in the 90's when they were watching their once great team sign poor replacements for departing legends. The next few years might be hard to stomach.
BReed
luckys - there's a lot of fans talking about the January window but I'm not even sure that Arsene will do anything then. He's said in the past along the lines of "we don't need to buy because we're in the process of turning Diaby and Denilson into world-class'". I seriously doubt that he's going to do a U-turn on his policy given how much he has invested in it so far. The only highlight that I'm looking forward to this season is the return of Eduardo and when he scores his first goal.
Gooner_Vin
The thing is who is there to buy in the January window?
Frosty B
ya but Vin, Denilson n Diaby n all the other youngsters in the team need a leader in there, someone to groom all the fantastic young players we have into world class players & warriors which they currently lack. n besides tat, this team is a bit short at the back & in the midfield. i know Arsene always double bluffs up when it comes to signing, but this time he will certainly buy. and we need a leader & Vieira is the only one. dun think he is getting much joy at Inter playing under that *****. this team needs a big big personality & leader right now & Paddy is the answer..
luckys_10
How about Yaya Toure?
Frosty B
i'm not sure about yaya frosty & then again i dunno if he would want to leave barca & come here. who to bring is upto the boss to decide, i trust him at that, what i really want is a big player with a big personality and a real leader to be brought into the team..
luckys_10
have been hearing that both podolski and alonso are both currently unhappy, it would be a revelation if we could go for one or both in january
cornish gooner
I think Ramsey & Vela might be worth a more regular spot from the start rather than the subs bench. We have to try something different.
Frosty B
don't worry lads you can come to our place next week and pick up a point - everybody else does :-)
merlin
I watched the West Ham match and I would swap Gallas, Toure ro Silvestre for Upson and I would give them Denilson or Song for Parker in a heartbeat!
Tom14
lolz merlin, i'm thinking about 3 points, not just one, & after looking at your form vs pool & united at home this season, it's not impossible :p
luckys_10
Liverpool didn't merlin. ;-)
JohnDoe
why did we sell lauren, pires and campbell? age would be welcolme right now.
KingGunner
Pires is the one we should given a two year contract to. I was gutted when he left and we badly missed him. Lauren was possibly the least one we missed out of the trio,
Frosty B
dont forget our 1 of 2 points of season against chaves lol
123spurs
Resignation..........,dats the word I was looking for. Diaby,Denilson,Song,Bendtner,I dont have preconceived opinions about these players,my opinions about them were conceived by these players. They are perenially poor players with very few good games,we keep saying they are young and learning their trade but at whose expense besides so is Fabregas. Diaby,especially is the most frustrating player I have ever seen,he never passes the ball until he loses it(if thats possible).But what does it matter,these players will continue to play bcos they might not be the fan's favorite but they are the managers favorites.If these players play well,they will be loved by fans or at least be left alone.RvP has had some fantastic performances for the gunners and reminds us all of Dennis Bergkamp,so we are a bit biased.Last season,he came back hungry bcos we didnt miss him bcos we had Eduardo. I wont be surprised if AW does not buy in Jan bcos he now has more to prove wit this team,he is a tad stubborn. The Arsenal project has turned into a nightmare.
D'arsassin
You should of signed Woodgate last January when you had the chance, hes a beast. I think if he was Jonatan L'Woodgateur from paris he would of done aswell!!! Well you signed Silvestre after all.
HuddersfieldYiddo
A good article LD. I don't think it helps to pinpoint certain individuals as having particularly poor performances - the whole team played badly! As ever the manager has to take the responsibility because he signed the players, he coaches them, he decides the tactics and he picks the team. If the players congenitally lack fight and desire it is his responsibility because he should see that they lack fight, desire or courage and change them for players that do have those qualities. It is also the managers policy not to sign players of proven character and quality but to rely on signing very young talent and developing it to the required level and until now this policy has largely been successful, unfortunately the manager has now been caught out big time with almost no maturity and long term experience in the squad of players he has to choose from. Signing players in January? Well, it would be nice if it were that simple! Arsene tells us that he didn't sign anyone in the summer because the players available at a price he could afford/was willing to pay were no better than the ones he already had and anyway the current squad was/is good enough. I think it will be even more difficult to sign the right players in January because they probably won't be available and we will be in a weaker position from a bargaining point of view. I hope desperately that I am wrong and that Arsene works another miracle and finds a couple of gems somewhere to give the squad a much needed boost. Having said all of that I think that Silvestre actually looks like a decent player, Clichy has plenty of fight - but a few too many erors at the moment - Adebayor and Cesc will make a difference on their return as will Sagna so it isn't all doom and gloom. Ramsey is obviously of the right character and so I think is Wilshere, however I don't want the futures of these players being spoilt by being forced into first team football too early as I think happened with Senderos and now Denilson. Above all we must continue to give the team our support on the pitch and save the booing and jeering for the opposition!
norfolk dumpling
These problems are so ingrained and deep rooted now i think it'll take years to sort out, really have a pessimistic hat on this morning but if our team had a load of Wigan shirts on Saturday would you really have raised an eyebrow at that performance? One thing i won't forgive Wenger for is saying we as fans aren't doing enough for the players at the AGM this year... i don't even know who acknowledged us at the end of the game Sat as i simply walked out when the whistle went, think the lowest of the low was Stoke, nasty atmosphere, everyone was mightily p1ssed off, now we just expect it. I'm not so sad or annoyed about Sat's result, i'm just truly worried, that if Arsene can't admit his 'experiment' is wrong, about the future of Arsenal football club.
shewore
Time for Gallas to go you don't want the likes of him at your Club
Tiny T
I can't disagree with your post too much norfolk dumpling, however, I think I criticised everybody whoddeserved to be criticised. I criticised Denilson and Bendtner and Song and Clichy, people tend to fixate on my criticism of van Persie because he's some kind of deity. I had the same when I said Walcott didn't play well against Villa and United, these are the golden children, thou shalt not criticise. Yet peoples eyes skate over the criticisms of players they don't like. Bendtner at least has the get out that he's 20 and still learning the game, though it doesn't excuse his lack of effort in the last half an hour at all. But RvP is 25 and I see little improvement in his attitude/ consistency/ effort. Shewore, most of the players came over but I think they were sent by the bench after attempting to walk off without acknowledgement. What I can tell you is that only 3 players came over in Kyiv which was unacceptable in the extreme.
Little Dutch
Absolutely, that would've been Ricey sending them over then. Couldn't agree more re Kyev, in Prague last year (when half the support must've got some form of trenchfoot) they all came over after a dour 0-0 draw, wonder if there's anything to read into that re attitude in the camp.. probably not ;-)
shewore
LD, If the players had shown that lack of ability, effort and stomach for a fight at the Grove they would of thoroughly deserved to be booed off and if they do that at the Grove they WILL be booed off. During the game they should be supported and cheered throughout as it will always boost the team. But once that final whistle goes, they need to be told in no uncertain terms if they were good or bad, regardless of whether they already know the answer. Spoilt brats need a bit of tough love sometimes!
LondonGooner
Talking of player effort, after the Villa game, only Walcott made a decent effort to come over and make sure he thanked uys for our efforts that day, despite he and his team mates giving us absolutly fack all to sing and cheer about! Whether he is a good or bad footballer, he's a one top lad and a nice kid and as such people are prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt when it comes to things like performances. I can admit to him having a bad game, but I am more likely to focus on someone else having a poor game such as say Diaby or Bendtner who rarely bother to even clap as they are walking off!
LondonGooner
That's fair enough LG, but I think like with the England team, booing happens so often at the Grove nowadays that it has completely lost its effectiveness. Much like when Big Brother contestants are evicted, everyone gets booed so nobody is bothered by it. Players will know they haven't played well and it will have hurt them, when they are booed it will rile them up inside and create a sense of "well **** you then!" I think it makes a much more effective point to see thousands of backs turned walking out silently. A bit like when you were younger and you had done something wrong, it always made a more pertinent point when your parents say, "I'm not angry, I'm just disappointed."
Little Dutch
You were quite right in what you said about the players you criticised LD and I agree that RVP whilst being a great talent needs to grow-up and lose that petulant streak, Walcott needs to add a defensive element to his game (although Overmars never did), Bentner and Song sometimes look lazy but I think some of this might be their running style coupled with immaturity. I think Denilson has done fairly well so far this season in a position he isn't really suited to but was poor on Saturday and ended up looking completely out of his depth. Perhaps his confidence is too fragile? There is a world of difference between genuine confidence and hubris and there is far too much hubris throughout the team at the moment. Arsene has a hell of a job on his hands and we will now really learn about him and the squad. Booing and jeering your own players is crass they don't need it and it doesn't help especially when confidence is so low.
norfolk dumpling
Oh I agree with your point, Im not saying either which is right or wrong, as with every parent, every child is different and a different course of action maybe required. People will still boo because that is human nature, it is far easier to say something when you are hurt or dissapointed than to keep quiet and "turn the other cheek" 9/10 times people will take the easy option, just human nature!
LondonGooner
norfolk dumpling - Confidence can be low, but effort should never be and that is totally inexcusable from any professional.
LondonGooner
To be honest, the result wasn't unexpected for me. Fabregas out, Gallas, Toure, Sagna and co were all out. If you'd won that game, I would've been MORE than gutted but I also would've started to respect your abilities once again.
ForeverUnited
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Arsenal Articles

Archived Arsenal Articles

List All Vital Arsenal Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Naijagunner 63
2. Amos. 59
3. Chippy Brady 57
4. Rocky7 43
5. Deltaforce 29
6. Guyfox 18
7. FunGunner 17
8. elbondo 17
9. julieloveshenry4ever 11
10. damiano_tommassi 11

League Results (view all)

Latest Results

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Arsenal 0 0 0 0 +0 0
2. Aston Villa 0 0 0 0 +0 0
3. Burnley 0 0 0 0 +0 0
4. Chelsea 0 0 0 0 +0 0
5. Crystal Palace 0 0 0 0 +0 0
6. Everton 0 0 0 0 +0 0
7. Hull City 0 0 0 0 +0 0

Breaking League News

Accepted Or Abandoned?
Hull City : 25/07/2014 09:50:00
Besic joins Everton in Thailand
Everton : 25/07/2014 09:01:00
Graham Among Players Left Behind
Sunderland : 25/07/2014 08:05:00
Returning World Cup Stars
Spurs : 25/07/2014 07:57:00
Carroll Out for Four Months Shock!
West Ham : 25/07/2014 07:45:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Which area does Arsene need to strengthen next?
Suggested By:  
Keeper 9%
Full back 8%
Defensive Midfield 61%
Wingers 4%
Striker 18%