UK time is: 15:48:11
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Half Term Report

I was going to do a broad half term report for the whole side, but let's face it, the team/ squad has been scrutinised to death as a collective unit and I don't think it's any secret where our hubrises lie as a team. Instead, I'll do a player by player appraisal of the season so far with the campaign at the half way point. Some players have been too keenly criticised and become something of a cause celebre for our current decline. Others have largely been let off the hook by our supporters when they are clearly playing below themselves. When appraising a player's performances, too many of us do so through the prism of media presenting their opinion as fact. Much has been said of the loss of Flamini whilst victim of the boo boys Hleb's absence is rarely mentioned. Adebayor is admonished for being lazy, yet Diaby rarely is. Eboue is a despicable diver but van Persie 'exaggerates contact.' As it is, was and ever shall be I guess. We're all guilty. Anyway, enough prattling.

1.Manuel ALMUNIA- Began the season in fine fettle, looking reasonably solid in front of a flaky backline. His performance in Turkey was something of a watershed. Eight days later, David Bentley lobbed him from forty yards and he hasn't been the same since, a limp apology to the away support at Stoke revealed it played on his mind and his reticence in decision making and his unwillingness to leave his goal line reveal he has been chastened by the experience. Almunia is a good goalkeeper, but not a great one. 6/10

2.Vassiriki Abou DIABY- Much the same as last season for Demolition Diaby, the talent is undoubtably there. The single handed dismantling of Fenerbahce and his saunter through on goal at Villa Park prove that. However, his problems have been two fold. Firstly, he is still incredibly injury prone and when he does make it into the side we seem unsure how to use him, though the supporting striker role seems to cut itself to the cloth of his talents. His biggest problem is his application, which is fitful at best. This has been characterised by several listless, idel performances punctuated by the odd scintillating run at an opposition defence. His ball skills are peerless, his effort is all too often disappointing. Apply yourself more Abou, we will all benefit. 6

3.Bacary SAGNA- Suffered with niggling injuries early in the season but lately has looked to have dismissed the cries of second season syndrome. It is no surprise that the regaining of form has coincided with his return to a sustained spell of fitness and with the injury to Walcott. Sagna doesn't know whether to sitck or twist with Walcott in front of him, released from that shackle, he has once again been one of our most reliable performers. 7

4.Cesc FABREGAS- Has not looked at his brilliant best this season, with Hleb sold and Rosicky sharing genetic material with the treatment table, more of the creative onus has been on Cesc. In an unbalanced midfield he has sometimes looked unsure of his role. However, we are talking underwhelming by the gargantuan standards of Fabregas, he still has 10 assists to his name in all competitions. The captain's armband had barely been fastened to his arm when injury virtually curtailed his season. 6.5

5.Kolo TOURE- A summer bout of malaria could easily explain Kolo's loss of form (not to mention his considerable weight gain), but in truth the decline has been more gradual than that. That he spent the last throws of last season at right back and that he now finds himself beneath Silvestre and Djourou in the pecking order tells its own story. Toure was never graceful under pressure, but often his electric pace dug him out of defensive mire. However, with the excess pounds and inhibited lung capacity have been unwelcome bedfellows of his virus. 5

8.Samir NASRI- A goal inside the first five minutes of your debut will buy you plenty of goodwill from supporters,as Freddie Ljungberg will attest. Having found the net six times thus far he appears to have acclimbatised quickly to the demands of the Premiership. He still suffers slightly away from home and has a worrying propensity towards niggling injuries, but all in all it's been a pleasing adaption period. With Fabregas, Walcott and Rosicky injured, the onus on him will increase in the second half of the season. 7.5

10.William GALLAS- Where to start? An awful beginning to his season saw him woefully out of sorts and lacking motivation, as fatal goals shipped against Fulham and Hull attest. However, since Toure's removal from the side Gallas appeared to be regaining form. The he decided to release an asinine autobiography and lose the captaincy in sensational circumstances. Since then, he has knuckled down and played extremely well, his abberation at Villa Park apart. It is nigh on impossible to rate Gallas' season numerically, semantically it is a precarious enough assignment. 6

11.Robin van PERSIE- His early season form was characterised by moments of individual brilliance punctuated by spells of anonimity. His talent is undisputed, his mentality and ability to be a team player have been seriously examined. The match winning display at Stamford Bridge appears to have given him a launchpad and thereafter he has silenced the doubters, Myself included. Let'shope he keeps it up, checks his temper and, above all, stays fit. 7.5

12.Carlos VELA- Bled slowly into the side thus far, his Carling Cup performances against Sheffield United and Wigan Athletic had Gooners and neutrals alike purring with content. Vela is clearly a player of mercurial talent, but listless performances at Burnley and Porto have shown he isnot quite ready to be tossed into the frame just yet. But most of us have seen enough to know we have a hell of a prospect on our hands here. 7.5

14.Theo WALCOTT- What to do with Theo Walcott? Electric in attack when given space, hopeless in defence, Walcott has come to, through little fault of his own, embody the flakiness of the current Arsenal set up. A potential match winner when given space or a complete liability when closed down quickly, Walcott personnifies our attacking set up. He is learning very quickly and the hat trick in Croatia for his country tell us all we need to know about his talent. However, I would like to see him develop another dimension to his game other than being able to run very fast. Looks more effective from the bench right now, but therein lies the learning curve. The injury could not have come at a worse time for him. 7

15.DENILSON Pereira de Neves- One of the season's few success stories in my eyes. Inconsistent until the end of September, he has learned his new role very quickly and rarely gives you anything below a 7 out of 10 performance. He has economised his game and 5 assists and 3 goals has been a sound contribution. Along with the fact that he is usually our most persistent/ successful tackler. 7.5

16.Aaron RAMSEY- Looks a much better player than he did in August, always comfortable with the ball and looking for possession. He still has a lot to learn in keeping his distribution simple and not hanging onto the ball for too long, but looks an enticing prospect all the same considering he turned 18 on Boxing Day. 7

17.Alexandre SONG Billong- Has been awarded a more prominent role this season and largely hasn't looked out of place. His positional sense is excellent though his distribution still needs work. There have been momentary lapses of concentration and he requires more urgency with the ball, but the job he did of keeping Steven Gerrard quiet last week show he is capable of these small improvements. 7

18.Mikel SILVESTRE- Hasn't really done it for me, the only games I think he has been sound in are the ones in which Arsenal have found themselves seldom under pressure- which is not a ringing endorsement for a defender. When put under more constant scrutiny away from home, his lack of legs and panicky demeanour have betrayed him. His performances against Fenerbahce and Burnley were close to laughable. 5

19.Jack WILSHERE- His nascent career has looked incredibly promising to date, the Carling Cup performances and his sporadic cameos have revealed a player who looks exciting and relaxed with the ball, as well as defying his small frame with a muscular aptitude with the ball. Though it is curious that they hype is so resounding based on a handful of appearances, let's allow him to develop at his own pace. 7.5

20.Johan DJOUROU- Another of the few success stories of the season, has always had an eerie calm with the ball and seldom lapses in defence have seen him dislodge Silvestre and Toure at centre half. His 6'4'' frame has helped plug one of our obvious gaps, but his composed temperament have neatly elucidated the comparitive flapping of Toure and Silvestre under pressure. Arsenal had kept ten consecutive clean sheets under Djourou's stewardship up until the game at Stamford Bridge tells its own story. Of course he interrupted that run by scoring an own goal! His reaction to his misfortune in that game was an increment towards his accelerating reputation. 8

21.Lukasz FABIANSKI- Showed grace under fire when thrown into the bear pit against United, whilst his Carling Cup performances have been cruelly overlooked in the shadow of Ramsey, Vela and Wilshere. His save against Wigan was the kind of breath taking stop associated with the best custodians in the game. I have high hopes for this lad. 8

22.Gael CLICHY- Other than a brainless error in the ill fated Spurs match, it's been more of the same from Gael. High octane, high energy, high quality. Has risen from the shadows to become an automatic choice and a constant feature in Player of the Month conversations. Has gone from strength to strength to the point that he was seriously considered for the captaincy. For all the pining for the Invincibles, how often do you hear somebody say, 'we really miss Ashley Cole you know'? 8

25.Emmanuel ADEBAYOR- Understandably much maligned following his antics in the summer, but 11 goals and 6 assists is a very decent contribution indeed. The United home match apart, Arsenal do not look the same side with Adebayor as its focal point. His hold up play and ability to take defenders away are unrivalled in Europe with the exception of a fit and firing Drogba and he is a lot more clinical this year. His development since we bought himhas been outstanding. You still sense there's more to come from him though. 7.5

26.Nicklas BENDTNER- Earned his shot after an impressive innings last season, but he lacks the attributes and the maturity to lead the line. The idea is often right with Nicklas but the execution is not. Has been unfairly chastised but its fair to say he has not grabbed his opportunity sufficiently. I feel his Arsenal career is slipping away from him and it is up to him to rescue it in the second half of the season. Has looked more threatening when manning the flank in an attacking formation, but that reveals his goal threat is not currently good enough and I recall Aliadiere assuming a similar role shortly before he was sold. 5.5

27.Emmanuel EBOUE- Hard to remember just how well he started this season, playing left, right and centre with equal applomb and looking a likely candidate to be this season's 'Flamini.' However, the malaise appeared to set back in in the Autumn before his injury. The barracking he received in the Wigan match will be remembered, his solid teamwork in some games won't. But the truth is, as a midfielder, he is simply not a brilliant footballer and one that wouldn't have had a look in in the side of 2003-04. 6.5

N.B. Please resist the urge to compare player ratings, they are purely individual. I do not think Fabianski has been a more valuable player than van Persie this season, but each players season has been evaluated entirely 100% individually and each player obviously has different circumstances. Cheers.LD.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Tim Stillman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday December 29 2008

Time: 8:33PM

Your Comments

How come van Persie is rated below Fabianski!!!!!! I have v. Persie 11 on the back of my Arsenal shirt!!!!! I love ARSENAL!!!!!
Tom14
Sagna doesnt even get a number...below the chart :'( Or above it :')
ajwb
So Wilshire, Ramsey and Vela all score higher than Cesc... wow.... way to go with those scores. Also Eboue and Cesc is equal..... nice. Maybe we should boo Cesc next game he plays, to balance it
villa
Villa, please for the sake of my sanity tell me that post was supposed to be sarcastic!
Little Dutch
Unlike myself, villa was clearly being sarcastic.
Tom14
Did you not read the bottom of the article Villa? The players ratings are made solely from their performances against their abilities.
Rocky7
LD, no need to justify your ratings, those of us with a brain can ascertain your decision making process. Only an idiot would claim that you think Cesc and Eboue are the same quality!
TPowell
hey tim, what about a report card for AW?
supersof
Fabianski top markings????!.. LOL...he makes David James look good..dear oh dear! The guy is a liability!
Orange Quadrant
I've actually been impressed with Fabianski. I can't remember too many errors from him in his time at the club, he's a positive goalie who always comes for crosses and a decent shot stopper to boot. His decision making needs work but that should come with experience, at the age of 23 I think he has the materials to be a very good keeper. Almunia's decision making is pretty poor and he's 31! Fabianksi also impressed me in the United game, he came on when we were under severe pressure and he came and claimed several crosses. Rafel's goal was a wonder effort and I saw little he could have done about that.
Little Dutch
As for a report card for AW, I guess it slipped my mind but it probably wouldn't make great reading at the moment. Besides, I want to wait until the transfer window is over before slating the guy too much, he deserves that chance. If he does nothing then I am afraid the braickbats will be out and rightly so. It is a desperate situation, we have to buy and unfortunately, due to his reluctance over the summer, he probably is going to have to pay inflated prices. Quivelling over a couple of million again on deadline day will probably see us lose around 30m in CL money.
Little Dutch
Shay Given will be our number 1 next month thankfully. Just 2 CDs, a CM, 2 wingers and a goalscorer required then! Ho! Hum!
Orange Quadrant
Wenger would probably rate 4 at the seasons' half term. Fair ratings overall and hits the nail on the head. Denilson is one player who has impressed me. In a team thats direly lacking consistency, he's one player who puts in a good shift, week in week out.
prits
What i wouldn't give for Given, shame the Ulsterman turned us down at the eleventh hour in the summer, what makes you think that'd change?
shewore
though i really like clichy,i think thats he has been making a few concentration lapses in 2008 that has cost us dearly...but you cant fault his commitment or desire to play for this club
fran merida
I tend to agree with something Rocky said a few weeks back, I don't think Clichy has made many errors. It's just he's been unfortunate that a) the ones at Birmingham and against Spurs were such significant ones and b) he makes so few errors that on the rare occasions he is culpable, it's amplified. Such is life for a player of his quality. As I alluded to in the caveat at the end of the article, if Eboue produced what Cesc has this season, I would have given him a nine, as it stands Cesc has still been very good, but we all know by that token that he is better than "very good."
Little Dutch
Overall a fair assessment I think and thankfully free from any obvious prejudice. I am not convinced that Given is who we need - he is a great shot-stopper but makes too many errors of judgement. Fabianski will be better! If the teams defence is sorted I think Almunia's confidence will return. Bendtner has been one of the seasons disappointments for me, he initially showed such promise on his return from Birmingham but seems to have gone backwards rather than forwards. Perhaps too much was expected too soon? Thrusting young players into regular first team football before they are ready can do all sorts of harm to their confidence and development, so much so that sometimes they subsequently never reach their full potential. That is one reason Denilson should be admired; too much was asked of him before he was ready but he hasn't let his problems affect his attitude or his development and we are now getting glimpses of the player he can be. Similar thoughts about Song. The boss should tread carefully with Ramsey and Willshere because they are so young although they both seem pretty tough cookies to me. The player I feel most sorry for is Toure because he is honest, hardworking and Arsenal through and through but everything now seems to be going wrong. I seem to recall that he was spoken of as a possible Arsenal captain not so very long ago. I hope the boss is able to make at least a couple of significant signings next month, but don't be too surprised if he doesn't because the players have to be top drawer and ready for epl action straight away which narrows the field a lot and our rivals aren't going to want their best players to come to us. I live in hope!!!!!!!!
norfolk dumpling
Good ratings in general. Let's split some hairs though - you have been generous to our forwards. Adebayor does show flashes of Drogba and Etoo in his hold-up play, but claiming he's one of Europe's top strikers is a bit far-fetched and the kind of adulation that got to his head this summer. The only thing he proved was that he has serious potential and might become one of Europe's best... it's hard to see through the dangly dreadlocks and assess whether he's going to fulfill his promise though. He scores 6.5 even by his own yardstick! RVP has pulled some rabbits out of the hat and he would have scored where Ade blundered against David James on sunday. Having said that he drifts a bit and needs to contribute more. By his own high standards he gets 6.9. I share the thoughts on Fabianski though - it's not even his saves - there's something about his refusal to drop his head even after mistakes which reminds me of Cech. This boy will be a commander of his box in a way Almunia doesn't quite manage. oo One thing I totally support is He is a fine developer but he has proved
Andy-bayor
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Arsenal Articles

Archived Arsenal Articles

List All Vital Arsenal Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Naijagunner 77
2. Amos. 74
3. Chippy Brady 59
4. Rocky7 52
5. Deltaforce 33
6. Guyfox 22
7. FunGunner 20
8. elbondo 17
9. NYArse 12
10. damiano_tommassi 12

League Results (view all)

Latest Results

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Arsenal 0 0 0 0 +0 0
2. Aston Villa 0 0 0 0 +0 0
3. Burnley 0 0 0 0 +0 0
4. Chelsea 0 0 0 0 +0 0
5. Crystal Palace 0 0 0 0 +0 0
6. Everton 0 0 0 0 +0 0
7. Hull City 0 0 0 0 +0 0

Breaking League News

Walk Away or Stay?
West Ham : 29/07/2014 13:01:00
What Price a Goal or Two?
West Ham : 29/07/2014 13:00:00
A Broken Team!
Man Utd : 29/07/2014 12:57:00
Moyes in West Ham Job Link!
Man Utd : 29/07/2014 12:56:00
Arsenal Midfielder Considered Quitting
Arsenal : 29/07/2014 12:53:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Which area does Arsene need to strengthen next?
Suggested By:  
Keeper 6%
Full back 6%
Defensive Midfield 64%
Wingers 4%
Striker 20%