Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

The Case for the Defence

The Case for the Defence

At this trying stage of the season, the issue of team selections is always going to be a prickly one. Arsenal were recently shaded by one goal in a very even F.A. Cup Semi Final against a team that cost roughly £130 million, whilst missing four defenders and a first choice goalkeeper and the criticism for the manager has bordered on pathological. This of course is because new signing and all round Golden boy Andrey Arshavin was left on the bench in favour of the brawn of Abou Diaby. Arshavin`s subsequent four goal cameo at Anfield has been used as a particularly pointy twig to affix the stick with which the manager is being beaten. Of course this largely ignores not only that Liverpool was a completely different game against completely different opposition, but firstly the lack of protection Arshavin afforded to Gibbs on Tuesday night, which was costly in its own way and would likely have been even more ruthlessly punished by Nicolas Anelka. But it also ignores that there is one manager in England who knows Arshavin`s strengths and, ergo, how to nullify them, better than Arsene Wenger. I will leave you to figure out who that manager is, but having watched Essien dish out an absolute master class in man marking against Steven Gerrard at Anfield ten days earlier, multiplied by Chelsea`s muscle in midfield to the power of Guus Hiidink`s inside knowledge of the Russian, I think Wenger`s decision made sense at the time he picked his team. You may think hindsight has proved Wenger wrong, I would not necessarily disagree, though there is no guarantee Arshavin would have changed the result, but I think the logic is simple enough for Wenger to be cut more slack than he has been in the aftermath.

With Arsenal now out of the F.A. Cup and with fourth place winking at us from the end of the tunnel, our focus is now more austere than it was seven days ago. When asked if players would be rested against Middlesbrough on Sunday, Wenger replied, "Yes, of course we think about it." In the same interview he explained that the prevailing reason for the slapstick defending on Tuesday night was down to fatigue. 'I am not happy with our defending but I believe that our defence has played many games and they were a bit jaded physically,' he explained.

'We cannot change many players, especially at the back. Offensively we have a bit more choice but at the back we haven`t got too much choice."

Of course this is a textbook case of Wenger protecting his charges; Gibbs has played the last four games, Silvestre the last three and a half and Sagna has just come back from a two match constitutional. Kolo Toure is the only member of the current makeshift back four who can justifiably claim fatigue. What Wenger does with his back four on Sunday will be very interesting. He will know full well that if defending as slapdash as that which was exhibited against Liverpool is repeated at Old Trafford on Wednesday the likeliness of the second leg being anything other than a procession will be high. Lest we forget there will be no Andrey Arshavin to dig us out of any holes (not that I would expect him to repeat the feats of Tuesday) and that Ferdinand and Vidic are hardly going to be as charitable as Carragher and Agger were in a game where circumstance forced Liverpool to go hell for leather. That said, Liverpool have recently garnered four goal hauls from United at Old Trafford, Real Madrid, Aston Villa and Chelsea. (As well as Fat Sam`s Blackburn). So we were in good company against one of Europe`s most potent attacking forces of late. However, the question is does Wenger stick or twist?

Whilst he bemoans a lack of choice in public, privately Wenger will know the chance for experimentation is open to him on Sunday. Upon announcing Gael Clichy`s back injury, the manager revealed he had thought about moving Bacary Sagna to left back, with Eboue in his natural habitat at right back. Gibbs has acquitted himself impressively for a boy with so little experience, but he will require his left winger to look after him. If Arsene has designs on playing Arshavin on the left on Sunday, this could be a move to consider. This time last year the currently in form Alex Song was afforded a run in the side at centre half and the option is also there to reacquaint himself with that position again, with Silvestre either moving over to left back or dropping to the bench altogether. Whilst the criticism of Silvestre of late has been overly harsh, it`s hard to argue that he has covered himself in glory in this three and a half game spell. Once again, familiarity might force Wenger`s hand again for with the United game in mind, as with Arshavin`s case on Saturday, there is one manager in the Premiership who knows Silvestre better than Wenger. Ferguson will have had Silvestre`s weaknesses catalogued for a number of years, selling him to us might prove to be the best piece of business in this season`s transfer market if Ferguson can feed upon these weaknesses and ensure United progress to another Champions League Final. However, Wenger expressed concerns that Song has not played at centre half this season and is therefore reluctant to fling him into that particular bear pit. The manager would also be aware that Song has hit a purple patch of form in midfield and will not want to countenance that by shifting him positionally. If you want an indication of how good Song`s form has been, ask yourself how you would have reacted twelve months ago had someone told you that his omission from the starting line up of a semi final against Chelsea would have been cited as one of the key reasons for defeat.

Yet another recourse of action might be to move Bacary Sagna to centre back and omit one of Silvestre or Gibbs. Sagna has the physical attributes; the pace and the bravery to play the position which might make Wenger think him better suited to the task of nullifying the bulldozer of Rooney. Whilst experimentation at this stage of the season can appear risky with so much at stake, most would argue that one of the biggest reasons for Arsenal making their only Champions League Final appearance to date was the emergence of Mathieu Flamini, who rather serendipitously turned out to be a decent makeshift left back. Against Middlesbrough`s shot shy attack, Wenger might well be tempted with any one of these options. Though it would be foolhardy to take a Boro side fighting for Premiership survival lightly, the price of failure on Sunday is less than it would be on Wednesday. However, Wenger will also be fully aware that the back four`s disjointed showing on Tuesday night would be a consequence of unfamiliarity as much as anything else. Silvestre was actually a first choice for a run of games in the autumn and looked assured with a run of games under his belt. However, he was partnered with Gallas in that spell, the Toure-Silvestre axis has been untried until this month, it figures that their first couple of games together might illicit signs of rustiness. Silvestre`s biggest weakness, other than the fact that he fudges his Alans every time the ball is played above his head, surrounds his lack of pace, but Toure has plenty in that department to suggest that he can make up the shortfall- as Toure has done for Campbell and Gallas. Arsene might be reluctant to break up the back four as it would give them another game under their belts as a unit and a crucial chance to enhance their understanding. So does Arsene stick or twist? Does he risk foregoing any potential telepathy? Does he uncover an unexpected solution to the recent defensive malaise? Gallas has been partnered with Toure, Silvestre and Djourou as first choice pairings this season, but it was the long term rekindling of the previously maligned Toure Gallas axis that led to our new found defensive stability in 2009. Experience might suggest Arsene sticks on this occasion and opts for the chance to nurture the roots of familiarity. These are the sorts of decisions that make or break seasons. As Lloyd Grossman might say, Arsene it`s over to you.LD.




For the very latest Premier League odds

For massive weekly jackpots - Play the Football Pools Online




Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Tim Stillman
Date:Thursday April 23 2009
Time: 3:25PM

Comments

0
Completely agree! Also the negativity amongst arsenal fans (from looking at blogs etc except for maybe arseblogger) is ridiculous. I was reading the online gooner and they said that if wenger was incharge of anfeild 89 then the game would have finished 2-1. I mean seriously what utter tosh. People pretend that Arsenal was a tripple european cup winning team before wenger arrived. This is only our second time in the semi finals of the european cup. For heavens sake people, why be so miserable????
operationmindcrime
23/04/2009 15:40:00
0
Completely agree! Also the negativity amongst arsenal fans (from looking at blogs etc except for maybe arseblogger) is ridiculous. I was reading the online gooner and they said that if wenger was incharge of anfeild 89 then the game would have finished 2-1. I mean seriously what utter tosh. People pretend that Arsenal was a tripple european cup winning team before wenger arrived. This is only our second time in the semi finals of the european cup. For heavens sake people, why be so miserable????
operationmindcrime
23/04/2009 15:40:00
0
I think that our defensive performance against the scousers had more to do with the way we set up in midfield rather than real problems with the back four. Not that there weren't any. Gibbs had a difficult time though he didn't ever hide and none of the other three covered themselves in glory. But with the exception of Nasri our midfield was woeful. I guess the pick for this game will based on what we want to field in the CL. There is a story that Djourou will be fit for the weekend so I guess that might mean Toure is rested against 'boro. Eboue on the right with Sagna on the left makes sense too though I guess the hope/expectation is that Clichy will also be available for the CL game so maybe Sagna gets more recovery time and Gibbs gets another chance to impress. The selection for midfield will depend on who we need to be fit most for ManU. I would guess Nasri, Cesc and Song are definite picks so maybe we won't see them featuring at the weekend. The cure for our defensive malady though lies as much in midfield as it does in defense. Arsene needs to be every bit as careful about who we have available in midfield as in the back line.
Amos.
23/04/2009 16:05:00
0
I think that our defensive performance against the scousers had more to do with the way we set up in midfield rather than real problems with the back four. Not that there weren't any. Gibbs had a difficult time though he didn't ever hide and none of the other three covered themselves in glory. But with the exception of Nasri our midfield was woeful. I guess the pick for this game will based on what we want to field in the CL. There is a story that Djourou will be fit for the weekend so I guess that might mean Toure is rested against 'boro. Eboue on the right with Sagna on the left makes sense too though I guess the hope/expectation is that Clichy will also be available for the CL game so maybe Sagna gets more recovery time and Gibbs gets another chance to impress. The selection for midfield will depend on who we need to be fit most for ManU. I would guess Nasri, Cesc and Song are definite picks so maybe we won't see them featuring at the weekend. The cure for our defensive malady though lies as much in midfield as it does in defense. Arsene needs to be every bit as careful about who we have available in midfield as in the back line.
Amos.
23/04/2009 16:05:00
0
I think the reason the fans had the hump also about the Chelsea game is that our leading goal scorer and most explosive striker, RVP, was played out wide on the left when we had a fully fit Arshavin sitting on the bench after a week off. A pretty stupid thing to do, when you look at it in the cold light of day. Our defence was under manned so it made sense to concentrate on the attacking options we had and he made our top striker this year totally ineffective. I am always an optimistic Arsenal fan, but if you cannot see that was a terrible tactical decision from the manager then you are naïve. Not everyone who criticises the manager is a plastic of fickle fan. Arsene knows best, that is true, but not al the time.
LondonGooner
23/04/2009 16:25:00
0
I think the reason the fans had the hump also about the Chelsea game is that our leading goal scorer and most explosive striker, RVP, was played out wide on the left when we had a fully fit Arshavin sitting on the bench after a week off. A pretty stupid thing to do, when you look at it in the cold light of day. Our defence was under manned so it made sense to concentrate on the attacking options we had and he made our top striker this year totally ineffective. I am always an optimistic Arsenal fan, but if you cannot see that was a terrible tactical decision from the manager then you are naïve. Not everyone who criticises the manager is a plastic of fickle fan. Arsene knows best, that is true, but not al the time.
LondonGooner
23/04/2009 16:25:00
0
"Stupid thing to do" - "terrible tactical decision" - "anyone who doesn't share my view is naive". Not even just the slightest chance that there was some logic in the decisions and that had we played as you suggested we would have been beaten more comprehensively then LG? I don't neccessarily agree with the tactical decisons in that game either but I am not naive enough to believe that whatever I would have done would automaically have been right.
Amos.
23/04/2009 18:08:00
0
"Stupid thing to do" - "terrible tactical decision" - "anyone who doesn't share my view is naive". Not even just the slightest chance that there was some logic in the decisions and that had we played as you suggested we would have been beaten more comprehensively then LG? I don't neccessarily agree with the tactical decisons in that game either but I am not naive enough to believe that whatever I would have done would automaically have been right.
Amos.
23/04/2009 18:08:00
0
I never said we would win or that it would of changed the result did I Amos? no where did i say that it was "right" either I made it clear it was a baffling decision and if no one could see that then they were naive. I see nothing wrong in what i have posted??? Not only am I haveing words put in my mouth but the ones I did use are being twisted.....just because I have a different opinion to you doesn't make it wrong Amos.
LondonGooner
23/04/2009 18:20:00
0
I never said we would win or that it would of changed the result did I Amos? no where did i say that it was "right" either I made it clear it was a baffling decision and if no one could see that then they were naive. I see nothing wrong in what i have posted??? Not only am I haveing words put in my mouth but the ones I did use are being twisted.....just because I have a different opinion to you doesn't make it wrong Amos.
LondonGooner
23/04/2009 18:20:00
Page 1/9
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Login to post a comment

Recent Arsenal Articles

Campbell - There's More To Come From Bellerin

Brotherly love

Premier League To Undergo Rebraning

Exciting news ... or just news ... sort of ...

Flamini - I Wasn't Trying To Hurt Him

Arsenal midfielder on his two footed tackle

Rambo - We Needed That Badly

Rambo on massive win at the weekend

Archived Vital Arsenal Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Rocky7
Profile
ClockEnd124
Profile
Amos
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

MOTM vs Cech
Suggested By:
Cech8%
Petr Cech92%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Leicester City 25 15 8 2 53 20
2 Spurs 25 13 9 3 48 26
3 Arsenal 25 14 6 5 48 17
4 Man City 25 14 5 6 47 21
5 Man Utd 25 11 8 6 41 10
6 West Ham 25 10 9 6 39 9
7 Southampton 25 10 7 8 37 9
8 Everton 25 8 11 6 35 12
9 Liverpool 25 9 8 8 35 -4
10 Watford 25 9 6 10 33 0
11 Stoke 25 9 6 10 33 -7
12 Crystal Palace 25 9 5 11 32 -4
13 Chelsea 25 7 9 9 30 -2
14 WBA 25 7 8 10 29 -9
15 AFC Bournemouth 25 7 7 11 28 -12
16 Swansea 25 6 9 10 27 -9
17 Newcastle 25 6 6 13 24 -18
18 Norwich 25 6 5 14 23 -20
19 Sunderland 25 5 5 15 20 -19
20 Aston Villa 25 3 7 15 16 -20
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Arsenal Fixtures (view all)

Feb 14 2016 12:00PM : Leicester City (H)
Barclays Premier League
Feb 20 2016 3:00PM : Hull City (H)
FA Cup
Feb 28 2016 2:05PM : Manchester United (a)
Barclays Premier League
Mar 2 2016 7:45PM : Swansea City (H)
Barclays Premier League
Mar 5 2016 12:45PM : Tottenham Hotspur (a)
Barclays Premier League
Mar 12 2016 5:30PM : West Bromwich Albion (H)
Barclays Premier League

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Naijagunner10
2.Afcdc3
3.Amos.1
4.Riversider1
5.Catcatcher 1
6.Wyn Mills1
7.princeoflove9091
8.Joe_@**1
9.Guyfox1
10.Galway Gooner1