Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

What Now For The Academy?

What Now For The Academy?

In a season that has ended potless for the first team, it is worth venerating the achievements of Steve Bould and his team in first of all winning the Academy Premier League title (showing real first team aptitude by clinching it at our official title headquarters at White Hart Lane) and reaching the Final of the F.A. Youth Cup. It`s often noted that English football fans have a prurient desire to see graduates from the Youth Team gracing the senior side. A brief glance around the Grove on match days will see the legend 19 WILSHERE grace many a replica shirt. This is an extraordinary leap of faith for someone who has made two and a half Carling Cup appearances, as well as two substitute appearances apiece in the F.A. Cup, Premiership and 1 in the Champions League. (Also witness the difference in the supporters` treatment of Bendtner and Walcott, both of whom I consider peas in a pod in terms of the current stage of their development). It also speaks to the enormous amount of pressure hoisted on the shoulders of young English players.

The level of invective levelled at the manager in last Thursday`s Shareholders meeting would suggest the word on the street is that Arsenal fans are tired of living in a perpetual future. "The experiment" as it is often erroneously referred to has failed, the over reliance on youth too stark for us to challenge for the top honours. As Amos pointed out in an article last week, this is something of a mis-corroberation of facts as Wenger has only signed one first team player under 21 since 2006. The voluble criticisms from the gallows yell, "experience, experience" (probably the same people that have Wilshere`s name on the back of their shirts and deride the manager for picking Eboue over Vela and blame Gallas for global warming), yet apparently we don`t want "geriatrics" with immense experience either. The manager himself has ominously told us he is looking for players who "aren`t inexperienced, we already have enough of those." In a climate where our supporters are apparently now unwilling to continue to invest in a future that lies at the end of a hypothetical rainbow, one has to ask where this leaves Steve Bould and the under 18s? I`ve no doubt that thousands will file into our ground on Friday evening to watch the First Leg of the Youth Cup Final as we take on Liverpool. I will also bet you my left testicle right here and now, that I will hear at least one comment along the lines of, "well player x who I am watching for the first time ever at youth level is much better than that geriatric Silvestre/ Eboue/ Bendtner." So the question of who will come through from this current all dominating crop is slightly compromised by the confused rantings of our own beleaguered concerns of our own supporters.

The last time Arsenal had a Youth Side of comparative success was at the turn of the Century, when the team of 2001 absolutely mauled Blackburn 5-0 in the F.A. Youth Cup Final First Leg at Highbury. Before drawing 1-1 at Ewood Park in the second leg. The core of that side has eked out an existence in the Premiership; Jermaine Pennant, Jerome Thomas, Steven Sidwell, David Bentley, Justin Hoyte and Jeremie Aliadiere (Premiership footballers for the next few days at least), James Harper had two seasons in the top flight with Reading, as did Graham Stack- albeit as a reserve keeper and Rhys Weston has drifted around league football ever since. The captain of that side, Ben Chorley, had brief spells at Wimbledon and Milton Keynes Dons before drifting off the radar. As Youth Sides go, that represents a good crop indeed. However, the key point remains that none were deemed good enough to play for Arsenal. Whilst we have made an incredibly good currency out of raiding the products of the globe`s finest Academy products and "ripping and burning" them into our own file marked "Arsenal Youth Products." However, players to earn the strictly 100% organic label on the supermarket shelf have been in short supply. Ashley Cole being the only Arsenal youth product of the 21st Century who has earned himself a 1-11 squad number. You can justifiably argue that modern, freewheeling, Champions League chasing Arsenal`s standards are higher, hence the lack of real emergence from the ranks. But does that not mean our Academy is not matching our status as a club? Are any of the Big 4s academies mining and cultivating footballing gold? Liverpool have reared no one of significance since Gerrard and Carragher who are both nudging 30, Chelsea don`t have any youth project to speak of having harvested nobody since John Terry. United have some squad members in their mid 20s from the academy in O`Shea and Fletcher whilst the likes of Welbeck remain unproven.

So who from the current Arsenal crop will make it? It is interesting to note that, in true Wenger style, many members of this year`s Youth side have played in a multitude of positions. Emmanuel Frimpong, like his namesake Eboue, has been tasked with the full back and wide midfield positions. Jay Emmanuel Thomas, the current captain, has played at full back, central midfield and in the wide positions; Rhys Murphy can play in midfield or upfront. The jewel in the crown is considered to be Jack Wilshere, who was a persistent fixture in the first team eighteen until the New Year, when a loss of form and concern over the premature pressure placed on his shoulders saw him quietly ushered away from the spotlight. Wilshere is a left footed player weaving his magic on the right, though Arsene Wenger and Steve Bould see his future in a central supporting striker role. Yet the supporting striker position is one that is traditionally well stocked under the current manager; Merson, Overmars, Bergkamp, Pires, Ljungberg, Hleb, van Persie, Arshavin, Kanu, - the list is endless. So will Wilshere realistically get the chance to flourish? Particularly in a climate where people are apparently entitled to make curt and crude remarks to the manager in the absence of instant success. In the late 80s Arsenal forged a team from their youth set up with the likes of Thomas, Rocastle, Merson and Adams. Nobody needs reminding of how Manchester United`s current standing was earned back in the early 90s. Isn`t it about time Arsenal produced at least one more gem from its ranks? In the modern game has the importance of a quality academy really diminished or has it just been neglected amidst the rainbow chasing? Arsenal`s current under 18 side looks set to be very decorated, but so too was the 2000-01side and not one of them were considered precious enough diamonds to sculpt into pricely gems. Many of us will crowd into the Emirates on Friday night to watch these young charges, but contemporary football shows us it is likely none of them will ever grace the stadium for regular top flight football. If it`s because they`re not good enough we should perhaps ask questions of an academy system that has waited nearly a decade to unearth a genuine first team player (though Gibbs` emergence might just break that glass ceiling). If they are good enough, the question lingers, are we as fans patient enough to let them develop. It would appear not.LD.

For the very latest Premier League odds

For massive weekly jackpots - Play the Football Pools Online

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Tim Stillman
Date:Tuesday May 19 2009
Time: 9:28PM


I wouldnt say it has failed at all, unfortunately some players werent prepared to wait that extra 18months ala Bentley and sidwell. Perhaps we would liked to have seen more come through, but as you mentioned Gibbs has broke through and he will push clichy for his position next year. Wilshere is outrageously talented and will blossom again, taken out of the limelight, he will prevail at Arsenal. Not sold on Frimpong at the moment, need to see him a bit more. The one I am looking foward to seeing in the first team is jay-emmanuel Thomas, fierce competitor, strong powerful and an engine to match,and also knows where the goal is. Traore has been out on loan for further experience and should get more appearances next season. The others to look out for are Lansbury, who got massively hampered last year through injury, and randall has the ability but his attitude has let him down. Then following on should be Freeman, afobe, murphy, nordveit and bartley. So there is enough coming through, but will the arsenal fans give them the time without no silver to keep them occupied?
19/05/2009 22:16:00
I was not really "around" at the time of that 2000/01 team, but I am sure than nobody was talking up Aliadiere, Hoyte, Sidwell and Thomas like they do Wilshere, Frimpong, Coquelin, Jay Thomas, Merida, Gibbs et al.
20/05/2009 00:22:00
I dont see why the fans wouldnt be patient enough. The example of Theo, when he's allowed to make several mistakes without being criticised is a case in point, which will be extended to other academy graduates as well. I'd really like to see someone graduate to the 1st team and was very pleased when Wilshere was given a squad number. Its understandable if they dont, as the standards are much higher, but I do believe that 1-2 of the current bunch will make it. Its pointless to pick out names as a lot of things could change - the most talented player is not necessarily the one who will make it, as attitude and mental toughness counts more.
20/05/2009 05:54:00
Maybe it's just me as a foreigner. Agree with Prits - I thought the Gooners in England showed great patience with someone like Theo, possibly because he's English. That's natural and I'm not saying it's a bad thing. It's only a bad thing when the likes of Bendtner haven't received the same level of support when they needed it. Since this crop is full of English kids, I'd guess they'll be given time and support that the Gooners have shown for Jack Wilshere. It's just impossible to predict whether they'll be good enough - let's wait and see until they're like 23, 24. What I like about this bunch of kids is not only their technical ability but their mental toughness as well. Gibbs is a great example, he's recovered from the disappointment of that slip in the high-pressure CL game and performed well these two games. The Youth players have also delivered results at their level when they weren't playing well in the League play-off and in the Youth Cup. These qualities will set them apart from other kids in England where, if we're honest, it's easier to find spoiled kids than mature ones.
20/05/2009 07:03:00
The point I was making with regards to supporters' patience surrounds the hypocrisy of the disenchanted amongst our support. They don't want any more young players, but they don't want "geriatrics" either. They want experienced players, yet they want players coming through the youth team. This looks a very decent crop indeed, but we have to start producing players now, we haven't had one really make it since Cole made his debut 9 years ago. If Arsenal's standard of player is higher now, then the Academy has to now show it has moved to reflect the club's standing and start producing at least one or two of that calibre of player. If less than two come through from this crop, you have to think that our Academy is 100% a breeding ground for other clubs. Let's hope a couple of them from this lot are good enough, if they're not, you have to wonder whether we're just not bothering with the academy enough or whether it is just not handled well enough.
Little Dutch
20/05/2009 09:08:00
Oh and the side if 2001 were spoken about in glowing terms. I think Aliadiere would have made it were it not for his appalling injury record in his formative years, Sidwell and Pennant were considered dead certs too, as was Hoyte. In fact, I'll chance every set of fans in the world thinks they have "the next big thing" in their academy. Ask a random fan of another club and they'll see "oh yeah, Jonny Wotsit plays at left back, he's 16 and being compared to Carlos. He'll be in our first team in two years." Then three eyars later Jonny Wotsit is turning out for Ten Em Bee and fixing roof tiles.
Little Dutch
20/05/2009 09:10:00
As you point out most other clubs academies have similar problems in bringing through kids from pre-puberty to the first team. Off the top of my head I can't think of one that has done so consistently. Brazil seems to the 'academy' feeding most European clubs. I think our academy has to be judged on the basis that it is financially viable - that's to say even if the kids don't make it to our level we can still finance the academy from sales of players like Bentley, Sidwell, Muamba et c. That way the Academy can operate as a 'finishing school' for players like Fabregas, Bendtner, Nordtveit, Coquelin and others that come with a level of development while continuing to mine for gems like Wilshere (if he makes it) that can reach our level. Like all gems though they are rare and difficult to unearth.
20/05/2009 09:27:00
When you analyse our season can you really say it was the youngsters that stopped us acheiving things? I would look at Toure, Clichy, Sylvestre, Adebayor more than say Gibbs, Song Denilson or Bendtner.
20/05/2009 09:43:00
The academy is a money making machine...Aliadiere was a real talent, i wasn't ever convinced on Pennant though or Sidwell come to think of it.
20/05/2009 10:14:00
"Particularly in a climate where people are apparently entitled to make curt and crude remarks to the manager in the absence of instant success." Erm, even Bob Wilson said there was only 3 or 4% of the questions would be considered abrupt, but not even rude. Lets drop that common fallacy immeadiately please? Also the bit about instant success and the people clamouring for more experience with Wiltshire on their shirts, the whole artical is aimed at a very, very small minority while the rest of us are being tarred with the same brush or lumped in with them. The people you describe make up a small minority of f***ing idiots and complete 'tards whose opinion means squat in the grand scheme of things. Couldn't agree more with you about the "produce one more gem atleast" comment, it's been inexcusably too long and teh much vaunted youth system of Brady has failed dismally to produce 1st team calibre players, fair enough they go to oteher teams, but we aren't here to stock other teams with average English players.
20/05/2009 12:53:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Arsenal Articles

Stats: Arsenal v AC Milan

All the stats from Arsenal (3) vs (1) AC Milan, Emirates Stadium, 15/3/18 Att:

Arsenal v AC Milan - Team Sheets

Arsenal are at the Emirates Stadium with AC Milan the visitors today, this is an 8.05pm kick-off - the line-ups have been confirmed.

Who Makes Southgate's Squad For March

England manager Gareth Southgate has now confirmed his squad for the upcoming games in the month of March.

Could Arsenal Star Have Signed A Pre-Contract With AC Milan?

I'm certainly not saying that's the case, but with Jack Wilshere's contract at Arsenal still sitting on the table, it's a strange set of quotes from AC Milan's Gennaro Gattuso.

Arsenal Archived Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Arsenal
Write For Vital Arsenal
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

EL - AC Milan MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Chambers20%
Sub - Elneny0%
Sub - Kolasinac0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Arsenal Fixtures

Write for Vital Football