UK time is: 19:01:47
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

2008-09 Manager of the Year

The folly of voting for a Footballer of the Year some three months before the season`s end has been exposed in full by the ridiculous, if sentimental, decision to give the award to Ryan Giggs, having made eleven starts and scored 1 goal this season. A Lifetime Achievement Award would not at all have been derided or undeserved for Giggs, but one feels the award has been forever tainted by this disproportionate decision. A bit like when Michael Owen was voted European Footballer of the Year in 2002. Similarly, the Premier League Manager of the Year Award should not be taken too seriously either, voted as it is by sponsors. There is only one occasion since the inception of the Premier League in 1992 that the award has not gone to the manager who has won the league. (George Burley of Ipswich in 2001). The League Manager`s Association Manager of the Year award appears to have more credibility, voted for as it is by the league`s 92 managers, the award can be won by a manager from any league. However, this award has only ever been won by Premiership managers.

The purpose of that convoluted introduction is to state that in the absence of any meaningful award for managers, I may as well stick my oar in and consider who the Premiership Manager of the Year is. (I`m not going to patronise anybody and pretend I watch quite enough lower league football to chance upon a consummate manager of the year. Though a good number of my friends would ask me to pipe up for Millwall`s Kenny Jackett, whilst a second consecutive promotion for Darren Ferguson at Peterborough would appear to contend Darren as a chip off the old block). The candidates are many and varied. You have to start with Alex Ferguson, even if you do so grudgingly. Back in 2006, when Chelsea dished out a 3-0 shoeing to United at the Bridge to confirm a second consecutive league title, the torch looked to have been passed to the oil fields of West London. Three years later and United have sewn up a third consecutive league title and teeter on the brink of retaining the Champions League, a feat that has never been achieved in its current format. Ferguson has blended the ageing Scholes, Neville and Giggs in with a squad of talent and promise. Wayne Rooney has been shifted over to the left wing with such great effect that nobody seems to have noticed his positional change. Carrick, Fletcher and Park have seamlessly replaced the industry and skill of Keane, Scholes and Giggs in their prime. Every new challenge that the league has served Ferguson, he has returned with a firm forehand. In Rafael, Fabio, Macheda and Anderson, there is a new generation bubbling below the surface too. Ferguson`s great success has been to successfully keep a squad of 20+ players happy. Could you even name a definite United starting XI were their whole squad fit? However, Ferguson is also a very well resourced manager (I should point out through resources he earned off the back of his own success and the Youth side of the early 90s) working with one of the biggest brand names in world football. So I can`t rightly give him Manager of the Year.

Back in March, I suggested Steve Bruce of Wigan Athletic to be a worthy candidate and whilst his team`s passable impression of Curbishley era Charlton since March has seen him slide down the rankings somewhat, his achievement in keeping Wigan gently treading water despite having the most salubrious elements of his squad asset stripped is still commendable nonetheless. It`s certainly not popular to afford the man any credit (particularly around Lancashire way), but Gary Megson has likewise steered the words "relegation" gently away from the lips of the Reebok punters with a squad that would not look out of place in the Championship. To elucidate, when Bolton came to the Emirates in January, they fielded only three substitutes. It sticks in the craw to give old droopy features any credit, but, as Harry Redknapp is so nauseatingly keen to inform us ad infinitum, Spurs had two points from eight games when he took over and now going into the last game of the season his side stand a decent chance of qualifying for the Europe League next season. (So if they qualify, Redknapp can spend the next six months whingeing about how inconvenient the competition is and how it is distracting for Tottenham in their ultimate aim to finish ninth). He has restored confidence to one of the most widely derided goalkeepers in Premiership history (the Spurs fans quite openly slaughtered him you may remember. Just as a reminder to those of you that believe Arsenal fans are the only ones that indulge this kind of practice) and has even made a decent fist of humiliating David Bentley, which is perfectly fine by me. However, the sheer amount of money Harry had at his disposal and the investment on the squad he inherited means he doesn`t get my vote.

It seems not a year goes past when David Moyes` achievements at 'plucky` Everton are not eulogised over and rightly so. The likes of Aston Villa, Manchester City, Spurs and Newcastle invest heavily and promise a serious challenge to the top four cartel every year, but every year relative paupers Everton are the ones that lead the "best of the rest" rat pack. This achievement is all the more laudable this year as Yakubu has been injured since November, whilst James Vaughan, Victor Anichebe and Luis Saha have been fit for a total of 12 games between them since Yakubu`s injury. This means Moyes has played almost half of the whole domestic campaign without a single recognised centre forward. Throw in a challenging run to the F.A. Cup Final which has seen them dispatch Aston Villa, Liverpool, Middlesbrough and Manchester United and you have further evidence as to Moyes` swelling stock as a top flight manager. However, he does not get my vote this year. Another strong candidate worthy of mention visits our hallowed ground on Sunday. Whatever the result, Stoke City are guaranteed to finish in 12th place at least. Whilst the pretentious purists deride their style of football, Pulis has focussed on the strengths of his squad and pitted them against the weaknesses of others. He has recognised that a side`s home form is key to keeping them in the division and has made the Britannia Stadium one of the unfriendliest places to visit in the top flight. Backed by a rambunctious crowd with a squad packed full of muscle and athleticism, Stoke have turned their home ground into a fortress- as Arsenal will attest. Stoke may not play pretty, balletic triangles, but they play positive, attacking football and show no hint of respect to any opponent. The second most vital aspect to a newly promoted side`s chances of survival after home form is usually the business they do in the January transfer window. In Etherington and Beattie, Pulis did arguably the best business in the league as the pair helped steer the Potters from relegation candidates into mid table water treaders. Dave Kitson may well have been a horrible summer signing, but Pulis showed no sentiment or obstinacy and cut his losses quickly. Rory Delap`s long throws might not yield the same acclaim as Ronaldo`s free kicks, but they are equally as deadly and it is therefore just as commidifiable and laudable a skill. But Pulis` real challenge will come next season as Stoke`s tactics are unlikely to be a surprise to anyone. The signing of the skilful feather-lite Etherington points to a manager trying to add another string to the bow.

My personal choice would be Tony Pulis in third place, whilst David Moyes teeters respectfully on the second place podium. Gianfranco Zola would look on from the "respectful mentions" column. However, the man that beats them both just has to be Fulham`s Roy Hodgson. In December 2007 he inherited a Fulham side that had already accepted relegation as an inevitability. The likes of Murphy, Kamara and Dempsey seemed visibly to be thinking of their next move and consequently going through the motions. Hodgson used the January window in 2008 to use his vast network of European contacts, forged off the back his industry on the continent, to bring in unknowns such as Hangeland and Nevland. He gave belief to an ailing side and incredibly kept them in the Premiership on the back of a monumental end of season run.

Hodgson could easily have rested on his laurels there. His reputation across Europe is secure and he was already assured a plateau in Fulham folklore. However, he has regrouped a straggling squad of journeymen and no hopers and added to them intelligently. Who would have thought that the likes of John Pantsill and Mark Schwarzer would prove to be two of the signings of the season? Is it any coincidence that sans Schwarzer, Middlesbrough have gone from mid table obscurity to relegation in twelve months? Hodgson, like all good coaches, started to forge his foundations from the back, with Hangeland, Pantsill, Hughes, Konchesky and Schwarzer forming one of the Premiership`s most formidable units. Not one of those players is a household name, yet Fulham have conceded less goals than Arsenal this season as we go into the last day. Stability has been the by word for Hodgson`s success as that back five have started 37 of Fulham`s 42 games this season. (What price that kind of stability at Arsenal?) Yet he has also added to the squad further up the pitch. Danny Murphy again looks like an international class midfielder and though the singings of Zamora and Johnson have probably not worked out as planned, Hodgson has shown his acute man management skills in transforming waifs and strays such as Clint Dempsey and Simon Davies. He also recognised that Jimmy Bullard, despite his impenetrable media friendly nice guy shtick, was just as avaricious as most modern day footballers when he prioritised money over his career with his move to Hull. Whilst pundits and Cottagers fans alike rued Hodgson`s inflexibility in bending to Bullard`s demands, Bullard was sold to Hull, dodgy knee and all, for £5m. He played 36 minutes before getting injured again. He will likely start next season as an expensive hanger on on a Championship wage bill that will desperately need trimming. Fulham have flourished in his absence with Dickson Etuhu (Etu-who?) taking his place. A Fulham win on the final day will see them qualify for the Europa League next season. Whilst the current squad will require replenishing to meet that challenge and Hodgson will have to spend the summer fending off the vultures for the likes of Hangeland and Murphy, European football could strengthen his hand significantly when he tries to convince them not to follow the path of Jimmy Bullard. Hodgson is unlikely to enjoy such a settled line up next year, particularly if the rigours of Europe are thrown into their schedule, but for now I raise my glass to one of football`s elder statesman and true gentlemen. Mr. Roy Hodgson.LD.

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

For the very latest Premier League odds

For massive weekly jackpots - Play the Football Pools Online

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Tim Stillman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Friday May 22 2009

Time: 2:04PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Good as Roy has been, Hiddink has to be there. He may have only been here a few months and is sadly soon to leave but he's been absolute top class in everything he's done. He's also the first Chelsea coach in a very long time to have close to universal respect from other fans.
Report Abuse
22/05/2009 14:39:00

From a Fulham supporter, many thanks for the kind words. Very much appreciated.
Report Abuse
22/05/2009 14:43:00

The_Legend_Of_Zola, Hiddink?! Come on. He had an almost £billion team who are arguably also the strongest(in terms of physique)! He just needed to peddle the team to the finish line really.
Report Abuse
22/05/2009 15:04:00

I agree with Thing. Hiddink didn't improve anything, just made the team perform the way a team with that amount of quality should perform. He's done a good job certainly, but third place in the league from a team with the resource of Chelsea is nothing really to shout about.
Report Abuse
22/05/2009 15:40:00

David Moyes done with a limited budget
Tiny T
Report Abuse
22/05/2009 17:09:00

Our Roy! Flabbergasted but a great article mate!
Report Abuse
22/05/2009 19:29:00

Roy Hodgson for me, then Fergie then David Moyes, my personal pick to replace Arsene.
Report Abuse
22/05/2009 22:10:00

Rocky, think about what you're saying. The team wasn't performing the way they should've and now they are. That's because of Guus. He's done exceptional at Chelsea and deserves credit. Your logic would suggest anyone can do the job at Chelsea, and well, that's simply not true. Still, Hodgson has done wonders at Fulham. He's overachieved there, no doubt about it.
Report Abuse
23/05/2009 14:16:00

I happen to think Hiidink sits alongside Wenger and Ferguson as one of the top three coaches on earth. However, he does have the most expensively assembled squad in the history of the game at his disposal, he's done a good job no doubt, but he's not even in the reckoning here. I doubt ensuring Chelsea finish 3rd will rank as his greatest achievement when one considers that he got South Korea to a WC Semi Final, worked wonders with Russia and Oz and won the CL with PSV (nearly twice, were it not for a flukey last minute Milan goal they would have been in the final in 05). For Hiidink to have got manager of the year, he would have had to win Chelsea the treble frankly.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
23/05/2009 14:37:00

There are many mangers in the Prem who I admire now. The likes of Moyes, O'Niel, Bruce, Hiddink etc. really are a fantastic asset to our league (we all know about Wenger and Ferguson), and I'm pleased Hodgson's getting some good press, having done a tremendous job with Fulham. The difference between being a great tactician and a great manager tends to get overlooked, and sometimes the likes of Hodgson, Bruce etc, don't get much praise for taking a long-term view of the club and working slowly to build and mould a club, not just a team. I don't want to sound as though I'm mindlessly bashing a manager here, but this is why managers such as Benitez will ever make a lasting mark on the game. He can win trophies now, but I would be very willing to wager that if his plan A suffers a set-back, and results don't go his way he will have no answer, and would probably start over with the resources of another team, unlike the lives of Ferguson and Wenger who can oversee the gap between generations, as we gooners are experiencing now, and guide the team amidst adversity to success.
Report Abuse
23/05/2009 22:33:00

By the way, anyone else follow the idea that Martin O'Niel has failed with Villa this year? I think they need to win or draw to better last years points talley.
Report Abuse
24/05/2009 10:06:00

Good call LD, although personally I would go for David Moyes. Hodgson has done a fantastic job at Fulham and deserves a lot of credt. But Moyes has had to deal with more challenges than Roy. Also, Everton have the one thing that the other pretenders dont have - consistency! They have finished in 5th-6th place in 4 out of the past 5 seasons and thats a superb record in consistency. 1. Resources wise, Roy and Moyes are almost on par. 2. Moyes has had to deal with more injuries 3. Evertons consistency. These reasons tip the scales in favour of Moyes.
Report Abuse
24/05/2009 11:05:00

You could very much argue that, but then Arsenal fans that contend we were unlucky last year could find similarities with Villa's season this year. Stupid late goals against inferior opponents cost them their momentum at the exact time one of their most important players (Laursen) got injured. In hindsight, a poor decision not to bother with a competition (for our 4-0 mauling in the cup at OT , read their loss to Moscow in the UEFA Cup), all coming at the same time. It shows what a fragile game football can be at times. Had Villa beaten Stoke they may well have finished 4th, had we beat Brum we would probably have started this season as defending champions. C'est la vie.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
24/05/2009 11:06:00

It'sa fair point prits, I actually forgot to mention that Everton alsolost Arteta in early February yet have still managed to overtake Villa. There'snot much between Moyes and Hodgson, but I guess I'm sort of cheating by factoring in the work Hodgson has done since about March 2008.Imagine if Middlesbrough stay up todayand Southgate then gets them to finish 7th next season, that's the sort of improbable achievement Hodgson has managed.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
24/05/2009 11:13:00

Hodgson and Moyes to be the joint winners. Hodgson for taking a relegation threatened team to Europe in the leaggue and Moyes for losing half his squad and still doing the business in the league. Frankly Hiddink finishing 3rd with Chelsea is the most mediocre of performances in the league (i know, 1 place better than us, thank you) considering what position you were in when he took over......3rd wasn't it?
Report Abuse
26/05/2009 10:56:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Arsenal Articles

Looking To Live The Dream? (Monday March 30 2015)

Jebb Loaned To Stevenage (Thursday March 26 2015)

Walcott Rubbishes Wenger Bust Up Talk (Thursday March 26 2015)

Ozil's On Right Path (Thursday March 26 2015)

Akpom Leaves For Forest Loan (Thursday March 26 2015)

Rambo Lauds The Power of Le Coq (Thursday March 26 2015)

Archived Arsenal Articles

List All Vital Arsenal Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Amos. 46
2. Naijagunner 43
3. Galway Gooner 16
4. Wyn Mills 16
5. Guyfox 11
6. Rocky7 8
7. shewore 8
8. paul_ownz 7
9. Joe_@** 5
10. Nwankwo25 4

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 29 20 7 2 +36 67
2. Man City 30 18 7 5 +34 61
3. Arsenal 30 18 6 6 +27 60
4. Man Utd 30 17 8 5 +25 59
5. Liverpool 30 16 6 8 +12 54
6. Southampton 30 16 5 9 +21 53
7. Spurs 30 16 5 9 +5 53

Breaking League News

Stoke Interested in Permanent Deal for Moses
» Chelsea : 31/03/2015 18:27:01
Ooh Saucy!
» Man Utd : 31/03/2015 17:31:01
United Set to Welcome Back Van Persie
» Man Utd : 31/03/2015 17:26:00
Mata's Spanish Hope!
» Man Utd : 31/03/2015 17:20:01
Twist In McClaren NUFC Link
» Newcastle : 31/03/2015 16:26:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Newcastle MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Ospina 12%
Chambers 1%
Gabriel 7%
Koscielny 1%
Monreal 0%
Ramsey 1%
Coquelin 12%
Sanchez 1%
Cazorla 7%
Welbeck 3%
Giroud 54%
Sub - Flamini 1%
Sub - Rosicky 0%
Sub - Bellerin 0%