Arsenal - Arsenal 2 West Bromwich Albion 0
UK time is: 18:14:26
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Arsenal 2 West Bromwich Albion 0

Carling Cup games are always a different experience, different crowd, different team, different expectations. In fact, they remind me of my student days, when I would make the journey onto campus during the summer months when all the undergrads were at home for three months, yet the campus would still be burgeoning with the activity of summer students- like an alternate universe. It was a tad disappointing to see some empty seats dotted about the upper tiers, I think Wenger has forged such a reputation for his young teams in his competition that I don`t think £20 was an unreasonable price to pay to watch them pit their young wits against an expansive and confident side like West Brom.

Arsene had taken the liberty of naming most of his starting line up before the match, presumably safe in the knowledge that Roberto di Matteo can hardly have had the chance to study up on the likes of Sanchez Watt and Gilles Sunu. Some more familiar faces were also present in the line up- Philippe Senderos received a warm reception on his first game back for sixteen months. Opinions of him vary (I think I`ve made it clear on this site just how highly I rate him) but I think everybody sees he`s a good guy who always gives his all for the cause. The much maligned Mikael Silvestre also lined up for his first appearance of the season, providing guidance and calm assurance throughout. The manager reached into the annals to pick the forgotten Kerrea Gilbert at right back- a feature of Arsenal`s run in the competition in 2005-06. Back then he looked all set to push Lauren out of contention as the long term successor to the right back slot. But a couple of meandering loan spells punctuated by unspecified personal/ attitude problems seems to have enervated his progress at Southend and Leicester. West Brom made six changes to the side that comprehensively thumped Boro 5-0 at the Riverside on Saturday, but that didn`t seem to take any of the zest from their game. Though the Young Guns could well have been ahead after as little as two minutes, Aaron Ramsey swung in a corner from the left and Phillipe Senderos moved to the near post completely unmarked but headed over. Three minutes later again, it was the same combo, Ramsey`s corner and Senderos rising to meet it but he could only glance it just wide.

The Baggies were not sufficiently chastened and came forward with intent; Robert Koren hung a high cross in from the right, Teixeira cleverly chested the ball down to debutant Jara and his shot angled just wide from the edge of the area with Szczesny covering with an assured dive. Arsenal hit back using a centrally positioned Jack Wilshere as their attacking pivot, Sanchez Watt played the ball into his path in the left channel, Wilshere using that gift of his to find tiny pockets of space, then pulled the ball back to the onrushing Watt, he stumbled as he applied the finish and the ball drifted and bobbled onto the foot of the post. Again, the scare appeared to inspire West Brom and Szczesny was forced into two fine low stops in as many minutes from Simon Cox and Robert Koren. The Baggies were beginning to impose themselves and Kerrea Gilbert had to clear off the line when Simon Cox bundled a corner goalwards. With Senderos, Gibbs and Silvestre at the back and Ramsey and Wilshere in midfield, Arsenal had sprinklings of first team quality in the spine of the side. But with Gilles Sunu shifted onto the right wing and the 18 year old Sanchez Watt asked to perform the thankless task of ploughing a lone furrow upfront, the Gunners lacked a bit of muscle and know how in the final third. I was actually a little surprised not to see Bendtner start the game to reinforce the forward line.

However, with West Brom looking ready to take a stranglehold of the match, an Arsenal Academy graduate halted them in their tracks. Not Wilshere, Watt nor Gibbs, but Jerome Thomas. After accidentally catching Wilshere in the face as the two jostled for the ball, Thomas offered a hand by way of apology which Wilshere seemed to refuse. Thomas idiotically retorted with a slap which earned him a deserved red card. It was a petulant gesture completely disproportionate to the wrong he had deemed done to him by Wilshere refusing his hand and, though di Matteo has looked to shift the blame to Wilshere in public, I am certain he will have had stern words with Thomas as it was an act of stupidity which ultimately cost them the game. Even at 11 versus 10 the match was evenly poised and could have gone either way, had the Baggies maintained a full compliment, they might well have won the match.

In fact it was the visitors who appeared to be in the ascendancy at the beginning of the second half and they really should have opened the scoring when Zuiverloon`s excellent right wing cross found a stooping Simon Cox who headed the ball inches over the crossbar. As is usually the case for the Young Guns, you felt that the first goal would ultimately decide the match and Arsenal did not look to have enough presence or guile upfront to break the Baggies down. Arsene looked to his substitutes bench and plucked Mark Randall and Carlos Vela from the shade and thrust them into the limelight. They didn`t disappoint. Within eight minutes of coming on, Vela showed the little bit of quality in the final third Arsenal had missed. Ramsey fed the ball into the Mexican on the edge of the area, he had the presence of mind to sense his surroundings and let the ball run past him, eking out half a yard of space, he unleashed a fierce shot which Kiely beat out and Sanchez Watt was on hand to slot home the rebound. For only the second time in the match, Watt had been able to feed off scraps rather than fight for scraps. Wilshere faded slightly as a creative force in the second half, something he may have to get used to is the attention exuded onto him by the opposition- they clearly regarded him as the key threat and doubled and trebled up on him when he had the ball. His team mates will also need to learn how to use the space that could afford them in the next round.

If one substitute had used some much needed quality on the edge of the area to create the first goal, Mark Randall was not to be usurped. Wilshere found Randall in space on the edge of the area, he clipped the ball over the stranded Kiely, the ball kissed the crossbar and rebounded out. Barnett senselessly tried to chest the ball back to his goalkeeper with Vela lurking; Vela muscled past Barnett and Kiely before impudently lifting the ball into the roof of the net from about two inches out. The finish had a playground manner about it, a bit like when you were a kid and had an open goal and elected to get down on your hands and knees and nudge the ball into the net with your head. In fact, I wondered for quite some time if the goal had been disallowed. With the game safe, Arsenal relaxed and played the sort of passing football you associate with them, Vela always looking to make an angle with his wide runs. West Brom might still have set up a late comeback. They probably deserved at least a goal for their efforts. Koren hit another excellent deep cross to the back post which Chris Wood met with a first time left foot volley which flew just wide. In the end it was another good win for the class of 2009-10. Senderos and Silvestre got valuable run outs and looked assured figures amongst young heads, Szczesny impressed and kept a clean sheet to boot which does his confidence no harm. I would be interested to see the squad for the next round though, Arsene tends to introduce a few older heads as the competition progresses and it`s fair to say that Arsenal did not really look to have enough upfront until Carlos Vela came on and changed the match. The prospect of having Vela fit to start the next round as well as a fit again Theo Walcott might beef up our resources. I`m sure had Arsene not endured so many injuries to forward players already this season that Bendtner might well have started this game. I also have to pay tribute to the opposition who, but for one errant member- ironically a product of Arsenal`s academy- might well have called themselves worthy winners. One would think a mid table Premiership side might well have been more clinical with their chances and therein lies a lesson for the next round. But lessons learned are what Arsenal`s philosophy in this competition is all about and the education of playing a tough game against committed opponents and coming out winners will be invaluable education indeed.LD.

Team: 52.SZCZESNY, 42.GILBERT, 6.SENDEROS, 18.SILVESTRE, 28.GIBBS, 35.COQUELIN (48.Randall `59), 16.RAMSEY, 19.WILSHERE, 51.SUNU (12.Vela `59), 30.TRAORE (33.Barazite `69), 54.WATT. Unused: 34.Bartley, 37.Eastmond, 41.Frimpong, 49.Shea.

*Try Vital Mobile FOR FREE for the latest news, scores, fixtures and so much more*

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Tim Stillman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday September 23 2009

Time: 10:16AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
On the Thomas incident when asked if he heard anything being said wenger answered ""My eyes are not great and my ears are even worse". Classic
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 10:29:00

These games are part of the development process though we seem to have opted for a fairly experienced back line. Is there really much for Gilbert to gain in terms of progress in Arsenal colours or is it more of a shop window objective in his case? You can see the potential importance for Sunu and Watt though a defeat in this game, which by all accounts might have been quite likely if they had kept a full complement, would have robbed us of an opportunity to take the development benefits of playing in the next round. Just as well we had Vela on the bench.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 10:32:00

Great write up Timbo. I haven't been able to see any of the match yet so the article is very appreciated. The game panned out pretty much as I expected. A decent win with a decent performance from both sides. I'm looking forward to Vela getting back into the swing of things, he's a player I rate very highly indeed and hope he can push on and earn himself some playing time in the bigger competitions.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 10:37:00

I didn't really learn anything new last night about players with future at Arsenal, just those who probably haven't. Gilbert is about 24 now (and wasn't very impressive), what's the point! I know you say shop window LD, but surely the time for that is Pre-Season. I got the feeling that Watt, Traore and Sunu weren't 100% comfortable in that formation (even though they play it throughout the club now). Wasn't a bad performance at all but if it was a half decent premier league side we would have been turned over. Vela changed the game, it'll be good to see him back in the 1st team.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 11:46:00

Gilbert's 21, it'll probably have done him some good to remind people he's still alive! But with Hoyte on loan and Sagna and Eboue very much involved in the first team, I think it was a case of him picking himself. You're right, I think Sunu looked uncomfortable on the right, Watt looked isolated and Traore didn't do a lot. But it's a good idea to play the same system throughout the club and if last night gave them another opportunity to learn it, you'd have to think they'll be better prepared next time. Practise makes perfect and all that. The rest of the side looked solid but the front three just didn't have the same experience as fringe players like Ramsey, Wilshere, Gibbs, Silvestre and Senderos. With Vela and Walcott hopefully fit for the next round, I think that side would be much more formidable.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 11:50:00

LD, didn't realise Gilbert was still 21 (am I thinking of his brother?). I totally agree that the whole club needs to embrace the formation. Wenger thinks it's the future, so the sooner ALL the players get used to it the better. Whose Hoyte on loan to, is it back to Watford? I'm also presuming Merida will be back for the next round as well.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 12:20:00

Will be interesting to see who will make it to the first time out of Gibbs and Traore. Gibbs did well in his stint last season, but I always thought Traore was our 2nd choice LB. Has Gibbs played left wing at all?
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 13:31:00

Gibbs started as a left winger and only converted to left back last season. I have to say, of the two I think Gibbs is quite a way out in front. I don't see enough in Traore to suggest he's Arsenal quality.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 13:34:00

If you look at the Wenger interview on he did before yesterdays match, he definately puts Gibbs above Traore. By the way (sorry for splitting hairs) but Gilbert is 22, 23 in Feb.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 13:56:00

Ramsey last night was definite MOTM for me. Thought Sylvestre was poor, let his man go at least twice and stood off his man twice for the keeper to make those 2 saves low to his right. Could blame that on ring rust though. I really worry about our CB cover.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 15:30:00

Yeah, the defence worried me a bit last night. West Brom had some good chances, and could have wrapped up the match early in the 2nd half. I was impressed by Wishere, Ramsey, Randall (sublime chip btw) and of course, Vela. A good result, but I'd really like Wenger to take this competition seriously. If the kids learn to win early on in their careers, it will surely help create a winning mentality, instead of constantly 'learning' from defeats - something that plagues the current 1st team. A good mix of experience (in defence, for eg) and offence (play Vela and Bendtner regularly) might see us with a good chance.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 20:52:00

I saw the name, Hoyte, (unless it is another Hoyte sibling) listed amongst England's U-20 team to the FIFA 'Junior' World cup starting this week; so, that may explain his absence, as against being on loan. I believe Merida is in the Spanish team to that tournament, as well. I would not worry much about the performance last night, seeing that the underdogs have a real go at it in these cup games. I take my consolation from watching laboured wins by L'pool (yesterday) and Manu (tonight). ManU could easily have lost had the Wolves strikers been a lot more clinical. However, we must put up a better performance, next game to progress.
Report Abuse
23/09/2009 22:48:00

Althought i didn't get to watch this game (tho the report helped a lot - thanks!) i have been a massive fan or Vela's since the first time i saw him play. The kid has a very natural first touch and that gives me a lot of time on the ball. He plays calm but also has pace when needed. He's gonna be a superstar. No one will agree with me on this but i think he is already a better player then Bedtner.
Report Abuse
24/09/2009 10:49:00

He IS a better player than Bendtner. He's just not ready for the physical demands of the Prem. That being said, we haven't got another striker like Bendtner.
Report Abuse
24/09/2009 11:02:00

Why would we want one?
Report Abuse
26/09/2009 05:16:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Arsenal Articles

Infographic - Most Fouled....Sánchez (Wednesday November 25 2015)

Stats: Arsenal v Dinamo Zagreb (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Match Preview Arsenal vs Zagreb (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Archived Arsenal Articles

List All Vital Arsenal Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Naijagunner 24
2. Galway Gooner 16
3. 0716389009 7
4. Wyn Mills 5
5. Guyfox 2
6. phreddy 2
7. Nwankwo25 2
8. Afcdc 2
9. Pat Rick 1
10. Will-i-am10 1

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Leicester City 13 8 4 1 8 28
2. Man Utd 13 8 3 2 10 27
3. Man City 13 8 2 3 14 26
4. Arsenal 13 8 2 3 12 26
5. Spurs 13 6 6 1 13 24
6. West Ham 13 6 3 4 4 21
7. Everton 13 5 5 3 8 20

Arsenal Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

George Best Tribute Tonight
» Man Utd : 25/11/2015 17:54:00
Hazard Makes UEFA Team of Year Shortlist
» Chelsea : 25/11/2015 17:48:00
Former United Striker Turns Down an Opportunity!
» Man Utd : 25/11/2015 17:39:00
AUDIO: A Revelation!
» Man Utd : 25/11/2015 17:31:01
A Wonderful Gesture
» Man Utd : 25/11/2015 17:29:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM vs Dinamo Zagreb
Suggested By:  
Cech 5%
Bellerin 0%
Kos 0%
BFG 0%
Monreal 0%
Flamini 0%
Cazorla 0%
Campbell 4%
Ozil 65%
Sanchez 26%
Giroud 0%
Debuchy 0%
Rambo 0%
Chambers 0%