Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

The Hypocrisy of Morality

The Hypocrisy of Morality

The moral high ground is, more often than not, the last bastion of the loser in sport. The notion of "fair play" is something of a deity in football. Much as God is revered when "miracles" happen yet apparently blameless/ helpless in the face of disaster, so football fans will wheel out the shield of fair play. The FAI this week begged and pleaded with FIFA to "uphold the integrity of the game" by giving them a replay. Strangely enough, when Ireland beat Georgia at Croke Park earlier in the Qualifying campaign courtesy of some incorrect officiating, I don`t recall them offering Georgia a replay. When Damien Duff dived for a penalty in the 2002 World Cup I`m not sure I recall the same media or FAI uproar. I`m also not sure why the FAI have demanded Thierry Henry apologise for his handball on Wednesday night, yet have somehow not asked Robbie Keane to do likewise- Keane, you will remember was twice penalised for deliberate handball in the match. Is it only intent to cheat when you get away with it?

You might argue that it would be natural for an Arsenal fan to feel defensive for Henry, yet I don`t seek to defend him. He cheated, there`s no question of that. But the hysterical reaction to his handball exasperates me, but it doesn`t surprise me. Frankly, people are idiots. The individual person is smart on occasion, but people are stupid, panicky, hysterical and lack the ability to think independently. The furore surrounding Henry is eerily similar to that of Eduardo`s earlier in the season. Manufactured moralising by an institution like the media. It`s like Myra Hindley telling children not to talk to strangers. Quite apart from the hypothetical argument that had the Irish won in the same fashion or had Rooney or Terry handled the ball to gift England a first World Cup for forty four years, the reaction would clearly be different, there are other issues to look at. Firstly, say the goal was scored in a different way. Let`s say France have a corner, there`s jostling in the box, Henry gives Richard Dunne a little nudge before rising to head the ball home. The referee does not spot the infringement and the goal is given. Is there the same sense of moral outrage? Is Henry publicly admonished as a cheat? No better than Ben Johnson or Maradona? Probably not, because we see players do this all the time. But is it still not intentionally breaking the rules to gain an advantage? You know, like handling the ball in the box?

It is EXACTLY the same. Yet the reaction would be entirely altered for the same principle. Yet for the past thirty six hours, I`ve heard various hybrids of frothy mouthed bile and hatred, mixed with naval gazing self pity. What is so utterly depressing, and this is not just true of football but of life in general, is how easily people are led and informed by the media, their sense of justice served to them like Pedigree Chum whilst they chow down on it like the subservient little puppies they are. You have to ask what right the media has to morally judge anybody given their despicable machinations. Handball is a crime on a par with paedophilia apparently, but intentionally deceiving an England manager into thinking you are an Arab Shiekh so you can get a revealing interview is fine? As I said, Fair Play is a concept wheeled out when it suits us- in that respect, it`s football`s answer to political correctness. It is informative that none of the Irish players have laid blame at Henry himself, instead castigating everyone from the referee to adidas. (Damien Duff came out with the adidas gem and Damien Duff has a boot endorsement deal with…..? Come on, keep guessing). It`s because they know that in the same scenario, they would have done absolutely the same thing. Ireland have every right to be sickened in losing a game of that magnitude in that manner. I am still bitter to this day that our 49 unbeaten run was curtailed by a cynical piece of cheating at Old Trafford by Wayne Rooney (where was the media`s moral compass then?) But I also know that that 49 match unbeaten run was at times preserved in an unsporting manner (Pires v Pompey anyone?)

The request to replay the France versus Ireland match was a ridiculous and pathetic one that would make most sports fans cringe. Replaying this game would set such a disruptive precedent, if every game that suffered a dodgy decision were to be replayed, we would never get past the first game of the season. The FAI cite the replay between Bahrain and Uzbekistan was different as the replay was awarded owing to a technical error. i.e. The referee saw the incident (encroachment on a penalty) but awarded the wrong decision (an indirect free kick to the perpetrators rather than a retake!) Ireland were desperately unlucky, but the whailing and whining of the FAI and the moral outrage of the media and it`s dribbling zombie consumers is entirely hypocritical. My favourite gem would be from Tony Cascarino, who lectured, "it would never have occurred to me to stick out my hand and guide it back into my control. I wasn't that devious." This of course the same Tony Cascarino who revealed in his autobiography, 1 year after collecting the last of his 88 caps for Eire that he wasn`t actually qualified to represent them. "I was a fake Irishman. A fraud." This is the sort of hypocrisy I`m talking about, Fair Play when it suits you. I feel for Eire, but it`s time to suck it up and move on. It is an absolute bona fide certainty that any one of the Irish fans who crammed into Croke Park and who were so vocally resplendent in Le Stade de France will watch their club team benefit from a similarly cynical act to gain a goal. Gauge how your reaction alters when you are the beneficiary. Henry, like Eduardo before him, is the latest sacrificial lamb to be offered to the brainless masses. But the responsibility now lies with the authorities to equip referees with the means to limit their mistakes, otherwise there will simply be more and more of this tiresome moralising as yet another non British/ UK scapegoat is stretched on the wrack. Kurt Cobain once memorably crooned, "Teenage angst has paid off well/ now I`m bored and old/ self appointed judges judge/ more than they have sold." Too true.LD.



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Tim Stillman
Date:Friday November 20 2009
Time: 1:54PM

Comments

0
I love the fact that this website offers me sane, intelligent and logical views. I too saw the footage against Geogia as seen here. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jf9fx4ipF4Q Watch how Keane blatantly catches the ball out of the air and then get a penalty which i still dont understand what for. Looking over reports its brushed of as the luck of the Irish. Not cheating, not tarnishing the game, no appologies or offers to replay the game? Hypocrisy and the fact its only little Georgia so it does not matter. And all these people sitting on their moral high ground watching super slow replays suggesting it was pre meditated and that the first handball could of been accidental but the second showed he deliberately controlled it. We are talking less than half a second. And lastly the idea that this handball is any different just because their was so much at stake. Surely we can not hand pick incidents from games which are seen to be more important just because it was someones dream to play in the world cup. Replay the game? How about we replay the game that cost us our unbeaten run because Rooney dived, or the Liverpool CL game because we didnt get the penalty etc. Bring in technology by all means but you cannot benefit from mistakes one week and brush it off and then cry when it goes against you
paul_ownz
20/11/2009 14:28:00
0
Appologies for the lack of punctuation.
paul_ownz
20/11/2009 14:32:00
0
Thank you, LD, thank you. It is absolutely extraordinary to watch the level of hysteria, vitriol, bile and hypocritical self-pity these last few days. I just watched Arsene's interview on the official site and he focuses entirely on the REAL problem -- the lack of video assistance for the officials. He says clearly that France won the tie thru a goal that should not have stood and that Ireland feel rightly aggrieved because of a serious problem that FIFA refuses to address. THAT is where all the focus should be, not this hypocritical nationalistic sanctimonious hyperventilating, the demonizing of a player into the second coming of Adolph Hitler and this selective standard that's directed only toward "them" and not "us." I don't know what the hell is it with this season but we've now seen 3 high profile incidents (Eduardo, Ngog and Henry) in which the moralizing media has gone in overdrive--which would not have happened if the player were from one of the home nations or if the game did not involve a home nation. A replay? Why not replay the 1986 England-Argentina game, then, ffs? Remember that phantom goal in which the Reading players (incl. an Irishman, Stephen Hunt) celebrated wildly even tho they knew there was no goal? They certainly didn't tell the referee. I recall MOTD saying essentially "well these things happen." So now Henry (like Eduardo) is akin to a mass murdering Hitler. Why people continue to view athletes as "role models" for their kids is beyond me. Basketball player Charles Barkley ruffled the feathers of Dan Quayle and the US sports media by saying "I am not a role model" and "A million guys can dunk a basketball in jail; should they be role models?"
jaelle
20/11/2009 14:32:00
0
This is a letter I've just seen printed on another website, Great To See People Aren't Getting Carried Away Please ask Thierry Henry to desist from associating himself with UNICEF. He brings shame on your great organisation and is a terrible example to innocent children around the world. Given half the chance he would probably cheat them out of the pennies they earn stitching his Nike boots etc Daragh
Little Dutch
20/11/2009 14:38:00
0
You have to be kidding LD. Was somebody actually THICK enough to write such drivel? Thierry Henry -such a monster he ought not to be allowed near anything to do with children. How sad can some people be? I have read some utter tripe these past two days. Most of it from the kind of people who obviously think that soaps like Coronation Street are real. They are the kind of nitwits who abuse actors in the street over a storyline on TV. Everyone here knows my sentiments about Thierry Henry. First let me say how DISMAYED I was watching the replay of the incident at the time. He did the wrong thing (for the right reasons under pressure of a situation of Domenech's incompetent management) and let HIMSELF down. But he put his country first (as every other player on the planet would do) and if the hacks in this country think that ONE error eradicated 15 years of exemplary service to sport, they have another thing coming. As with the Eduardo affair, SOME PERSPECTIVE please. Time for Technology.
julieloveshenry4ever
20/11/2009 15:10:00
0
Henry should be ashamed of himself. This was the most disgusting thing I've ever seen, I'm going to set up a facebook group called 'Henry must die'. We need to make an example of him so that the poor children in Africa don't sleep hungry tonight.
Saf 91
20/11/2009 15:18:00
0
Before I get a mass flaming my way, I was joking...... People forget that France should have had a penalty and a one-man advantage. But don't let facts get in the way of a chance for the Daily Fail to get on their high horses!
Saf 91
20/11/2009 15:20:00
0
thanks for that video link paul, I'm sure Robbie Keane ran off and did 5 cartwheels and shot his hand-guns off after converting a penalty that was rewarded for a tackle that occurred a good 5 feet outside the box... I agree with the FAI, Georgia should definitely get a replay after that result!
TPowell
20/11/2009 15:27:00
0
To be fair, I think the reaction of most Irish fans has been more magnanimous than that, but it is an insight into how easily people allow themselves to be whipped into frenzy. Ironically, I'm minded of a perfectly good goal Henry scored away at CSKA Moskva a couple of years ago which was disallowed for handball when we were trailing 1-0 in the 86th minute.
Little Dutch
20/11/2009 15:36:00
0
And he got booked LD.
paul_ownz
20/11/2009 15:42:00
Page 1/8
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8

Login to post a comment

Recent Arsenal Articles

Back To The Drawing Board After Vardy Snub

Gunners search for a striker continues

Six Clubs Set 2015/16 Premiership Records

Who were the six clubs to register a record breaking or equalling 2015/16 campaign?

Xhaka Likes To Beat Manchester United

Who doesn't?

A Faint Whiff of Premier League Action

The fixtures are here

Archived Vital Arsenal Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Rocky7
Editor email
Profile
ClockEnd124
no email
Profile
Amos
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Player of the Year
Suggested By:
Petr Cech4%
Hector Bellerin7%
Mesut Ozil78%
Alexis Sanchez8%
Olivier Giroud3%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Leicester City 38 23 12 3 81 32
2 Arsenal 38 20 11 7 71 29
3 Spurs 38 19 13 6 70 34
4 Man City 38 19 9 10 66 30
5 Man Utd 38 19 9 10 66 14
6 Southampton 38 18 9 11 63 18
7 West Ham 38 16 14 8 62 14
8 Liverpool 38 16 12 10 60 13
9 Stoke 38 14 9 15 51 -14
10 Chelsea 38 12 14 12 50 6
11 Everton 38 11 14 13 47 4
12 Swansea 38 12 11 15 47 -10
13 Watford 38 12 9 17 45 -10
14 WBA 38 10 13 15 43 -14
15 Crystal Palace 38 11 9 18 42 -12
16 AFC Bournemouth 38 11 9 18 42 -22
17 Sunderland 38 9 12 17 39 -14
R Newcastle 38 9 10 19 37 -21
R Norwich 38 9 7 22 34 -28
R Aston Villa 38 3 8 27 17 -49
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Naijagunner7
2.Mike2942
3.Joe_@**1
4.Louis9991
5.princeoflove9091