Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

Fabianski still has time

Fabianski still has time

My first thought after the Wigan game in which we fashioned an unlikely defeat in large part due to an error by Fabianski was that Wenger was wrong to put him into that game but maybe it was less of a reactive decision than I at first thought. If Almunia was genuinely injured then Wenger would have had no real choice but there was a suspicion following the defeat at WHL that with an outside chance of the title gone if Fabianski was to be allowed a run then this would have to be the time.

His performance in the CL game away to Porto didn`t help his confidence or any confidence in him but there wasn`t a great deal to lose in terms of our league position either. Had we won all the remaining PL matches after the Spurs game we would still have only managed 3rd place. It would be the sort of calculation Wenger would have made in deciding to risk a reputation damaged in Portugal in the belief Fabianski could redeem himself. If Wenger was to make a decision in the summer upon recruiting another keeper it would have been important to take advantage of the last 4 PL games of the season to test Lukasz in competitive match conditions without risking anything other than the ire of followers of the club. The results wouldn`t have helped him greatly.

In a perverse way the errors Fabianski made in the games against Wigan and Blackburn could be seen as more encouraging than a fundamental flaw in technique or decision making might be. They were handling errors which you would expect could be remedied if confidence could be acquired but that would only ever come about by accepting the mistakes in games that have no consequence in return for the opportunity to learn a lesson. The problems he encountered in the Blackburn game were ones that Lehmann struggled with throughout his Arsenal career without ever really mastering. That aside his performance at Blackburn was good with some technically very good saves.

David Seaman, 3 times a title winner with Arsenal, feels that Wenger might stay with both Fabianski and Almunia next season. Web site claims in an exclusive interview that Seaman told them:

"They`re still learning, especially Fabianski - people forget how young he is. He`s a great talent but he still needs to develop his all round game. It will come with age, but he`s certainly a talent.

"Then you look at Almunia who has all the experience...I think he`s going to have a problem in keeping Fabianski out. It`s great though to have competition for that one spot, Arsenal need it to be competitive as it will bring out the best in them.

"I think he`ll stay with the first choice pair he has at the moment. If you include Vito [Mannone] he`s got three with first team experience.

"Then you look at Wojciech Szczesny coming through and you have to say he`s a fascinating prospect. I think he may be a little young to throw straight into the first team as being in goal for Arsenal is very different to being in goal at Brentford. He is a great, great talent though - so Arsene`s got four top players at his disposal.

"I don`t know for sure what he`ll do but I accept it`s a tough situation when the fans are calling for change."

The threatened protests next season if Arsenal haven`t signed another keeper won`t persuade Wenger to sign someone just to appease discontented followers which suggests that if he does sign anyone it would have to be one with a proven pedigree at a high level rather than players like Joe Hart who despite a good season with Birmingham would still be less proven than Almunia. If he can`t command a place in the Manchester City squad in front of Given why would we imagine he would fare any better at the Emirates?

If a keeper is to be signed then as Wenger did with the then 34 year old Lehmann he would be safer in terms of supporter credibility in opting for an experienced and established player with a notable CV to replace Almunia whose lack of playing credentials has and will always be counted against him. That would still leave Fabianski space and the time his relative youth allows to convince those that the calamities can be eliminated in the hope that the much lauded Szczesny will eventually realise the potential that many see in him. Both need someone else to bear the weight of expectation which has proved such a burden for Almunia.

It would be brave, though not untypical, of Wenger to go into next season with the same keepers but maybe this is an occasion when it makes sense to give the discontented what they want and sign an international keeper with a proven track record just to take the heat off that aspect of the team. There would be little point in signing another promising keeper without the badges on his arm that would allow his errors to be dismissed as readily as they would for a keeper with a 'name'. Finding such a keeper is easier said than done. I don't suppose David James would provide quite the same excitement in the playground that signing Buffon might do but how many such keepers are there? It would mean the sacrifice of a decent keeper in Almunia who in many ways might seem a better number two at present than Fabianski but if it`s ever right to offer a ritual bloodletting to followers then that would be the one that would have to be made.

It's a cruel game. There will still be no gain without pain for Fabianski but maybe for Almunia pain relief will be the more pragmatic act though replacing him with someone demonstrably better rather than potentially better isn`t as straightforward as we might wish it to be. We already have potential enough.

Join Vital Arsenal

Want to comment on this article? It's easy to register , simply click the link and enjoy getting involved (you can even win prizes!)

Message Board To visit the message board, click here. Get involved

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Monday May 17 2010
Time: 12:03PM


My sentiments exactly, I think given the fact that we have 3 young keepers, none of whom are quite ready yet to play week in week out at the level we require, a stopgap Lehmann style signing wuld be the best thing. Almunia will go I think, Wenger was very candid after the Spurs game when he said, "I never said Almunia was my long term number 1." I think that will have hurt Almunia sufficiently to hasten his departure and I often wonder if his recent "injury" was as much to do with hurt pride on his part than giving Fabianski a chance.
Little Dutch
17/05/2010 12:20:00
People need to stop using age as an excuse, it's completely boring. Fabianksi is older now than Cech after the former had won 2 league titles. And your point re Joe Hart is fundamentally flawed because he's pretty much a cert for the no.1 jersey there next season. You also harp on about the "blood letting" and other such typical swipes at the support, as if you're completely tired and above all of the criticism of the goalkeeping situation and that the fans are wrong to voice their opinions on what is clearly a weak position for us.
17/05/2010 12:32:00
Cech is a special player. Its like saying Denilson should be as good as Vieira was at 19 because he's 21.
17/05/2010 12:39:00
Would love Almunia to be sold, but who in their right mind would buy him?!
17/05/2010 12:44:00
I'm pointint out that age is not an excuse, nobody wants to hear that anymore. And why anyone would mention the pedestrian and average Denilson in the same breath as an Arsenal legend and warrior is beyond me.
17/05/2010 12:48:00
Great, balanced article Amos. Is James better than Almunia? Would be interesting to hear what Seaman thinks. Has he proven himself to be a good professional with good leadership abilities? Yes. Is he more adept at handling pressure situations at a big club? I think it would be harsh on Almunia to suggest that James is any better at this criteria. Is James more likely to move clubs than Buffon? Yes.
17/05/2010 12:51:00
"he's pretty much a cert for the no.1 jersey there next season". I'm far from convinced about that, and Tom's point is valid, players develop at different ages - look at Arshavin, who only really showed his class at 27, and thats for an outfield, attacking player. I personally don't think Fabianski will become the number 1 here, especially now all the supporters have lost all faith in him, but all the same, he has brilliant reflexes and is very decisive. As mentioned, all he needs is a bit more conviction.
17/05/2010 12:52:00
For those who profess Almunia's lack of quality, and I'm not explicitly agreeing or disagreeing here, just look at the change in reputations of other GKs. I remember clearly just a couple of years ago a lot of Arsenal fans harping on about how jelous they were of Man United for having Ben Foster. I also remember tonnes of fans saying Rob Green is world-class (some still do, which is rediculous). Everyone now loves David James, and he is a good keeper, but the hate he recieved following his errors in an England shirt a few years ago are now forgotten. People were even saying that Van der Sar had lost it about a year and a half ago following some dodgy moments with Man U, not to mention the Chelsea fans earlier this season who were berrating Cech. It's a position where reputations fluctuate hugely, and just as Almunia was starting to convince people that he was our rightful number 1 last year, so a little patience might let him redeem that confidence.
17/05/2010 12:59:00
Seaman was the bore 'excusing' Fab on the basis of age. If Hart is to be no.1 at Citeh next season then obviously we wouldn't sign him anyway but my point was that if we're going to sign a keeper then it needs to be someone with a bit more of a track record than one decent season with a mid table club no matter how promising (hence someone 'like' Hart) he might appear to be. I don't think followers would have the appetite for anything other than someone with a CV behind them.
17/05/2010 13:04:00
We've been more than patient enough with someone who's not even remotely close to his international squad, i'd hazard a guess that half of Spain don't even know who Manwell is. Hughied, where on earth has Almunia proven his leadership capabilites? He's an absolute novice in terms of games played for his age, even if you compare him to Cesc's appearances for us. The players have lost faith in him, this I think is obvious in their body language, just have a look at Sagna after the Tottenham goal gesturing towards Almunia after his hollywood punch and typical role or two to make it look better. The 'keeper situation cost us far too many points last season, a mistake that Wenger can't make this year is to allow that to continue, that'd be his biggest ever clanger in my opinion.
17/05/2010 13:15:00
Page 1/9
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Login to post a comment

Recent Arsenal Articles

Stats: Arsenal v AC Milan

All the stats from Arsenal (3) vs (1) AC Milan, Emirates Stadium, 15/3/18 Att:

Arsenal v AC Milan - Team Sheets

Arsenal are at the Emirates Stadium with AC Milan the visitors today, this is an 8.05pm kick-off - the line-ups have been confirmed.

Who Makes Southgate's Squad For March

England manager Gareth Southgate has now confirmed his squad for the upcoming games in the month of March.

Could Arsenal Star Have Signed A Pre-Contract With AC Milan?

I'm certainly not saying that's the case, but with Jack Wilshere's contract at Arsenal still sitting on the table, it's a strange set of quotes from AC Milan's Gennaro Gattuso.

Arsenal Archived Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Arsenal
Write For Vital Arsenal
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

EL - AC Milan MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Chambers20%
Sub - Elneny0%
Sub - Kolasinac0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Arsenal Fixtures

Vital Football Comment