UK time is: 10:28:02
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Jeepers, Keepers

With the acquisition of a new goalkeeper looking very unlikely, Arsenal are going to have to go the tried and tested route in between the sticks on Sunday. Nobody seems too sure who Arsenal`s current first choice goalkeeper is at the moment, indeed, we could see any one of our four first team goalies manning the posts at Anfield. I`m sure the manager is trying to promote competition by keeping his cards close to his chest; but I am not entirely sure that that is such a healthy situation for the fragile confidence of some of our custodians nor for the defence selected to play in front of them. The mystery box goalie didn`t work out too well for Capello and Rob Green this summer as I recall. Either that or the manager genuinely expected to have bought someone in by now to be bona fide first choice. Anyway, that certainly won`t happen in time for Sunday, so who should play?

Manuel ALMUNIA
The case for: Sufficiently dry behind the ears, at 33 Almunia is our most experienced option, he has played and played well at Anfield before and he is the most familiar option with the defence. Almunia doesn`t make as many catastrophic errors as people make out; he`s had three seasons as our number 1 and has heard every criticism going. They say good judgement comes from experience, experience comes from bad judgement and Almunia has a plentiful enough history of both by now. Arsenal fans explicitly refuse to point out his good points as a keeper, but he does have them. He almost never fumbles crosses (though his propensity to punch unnecessarily is annoying) and his record with penalties is better than David Seaman`s. Our other three options are youthful wild cards; all three are probably just as likely to lose us the game as win it. We know what we`re getting with Almunia and he is the safest option we have.

The case against: The dislike of Almunia; from supporters and the media, has reached hysterical proportions and his reputation is unlikely to ever be viewed positively in North London again. The pressure on him will be intense, the concession of any sort of goal will be forensically analysed and construed as his fault, whether that be the case or not. Almunia`s confidence is unlikely to be high, he has been only a sporadic presence in pre season and the manager has hardly been at hand with ringing endorsement. His assertion in May that "I never said Almunia was my long term number 1" combined with yet another "illness" enforced absence for the remaining league fixtures of last year point to the fact that Almunia does not have a future at the club. The persistent chase for the distinctly average Schwarzer won`t have bridged any rifts in that regard.

Lukasz FABIANSKI
The case for: There is an outstanding goalkeeper in there somewhere, elastic limbed and agile; he is still capable of pulling off the sort of saves I don`t think other Arsenal keepers are. Arsenal are away from home to a rival and will inevitably spend time on the back foot, Fabianski is a positive goalkeeper who sweeps up well around his area. The manager clearly still has faith in him despite his mistakes last season. Most of those errors came in inconsequential games and the experience should stand him in good stead. Having appeared in most of our pre season games, he should be more finely tuned than our other choices. The game is also away from home, away from the jeering stupidity of the people who are supposed to support the club. On the Members Day there was an audible ironic jeer when Bob Wilson announced an on pitch competition where supporters were invited to compare their reflexes with Fabianski. A solid performance at Anfield could restore is reputation and unleash the talented goalkeeper lying somewhere amidst the wreckage of last spring.

The case against: His confidence appears to be absolutely shot to bits, in his last five or sic games he has made at least one glaring error. The rigours of a pre season friendly in his native Warsaw seemed too much for his fragile nerves and it`s a massive risk to have such an accident prone goalkeeper for our opening game. Whereas a good performance could help partially restore his reputation, another mistake will surely finish him off on these shores. Liverpool v Arsenal is a huge game in the fixture calendar which attracts a global audience; eyes will be boring into the back of his skull, willing him to commit another error straight from the comedy reel. He could recover from his errors in the manner that Huerelho Gomes did, but I think it more likely he will go the way of Alex Manninger as a talent buried under the glare of a suspicious public. Fabianski cannot have the confidence of his defence; he certainly does not have the confidence of the supporters. There is a fine line between a manager showing faith and a manager showing blind faith.

Vito MANNONE
The case for: Having been out of the team for the last ten months, everyone has pretty much forgotten how many errors he made when he was first in the team! The spell in between sticks last season will have been a valuable learning curve for him and the performance at Craven Cottage seems to have glossed over the general anxiety he showed for every other game for which he was in goal. The credit he has locked in the bank would mean he would probably be the least harshly scrutinised of the four possible choices and therefore most likely the most relaxed. He has had a good number of minutes in pre season, saving a penalty and generally doing all that has been asked of him. The performance at Fulham last year suggests he has it in him to be a match winner.

The case against: He hardly convinced in his spell in the first team last season; his judgement is still rather erratic and the defence didn`t display a lot of confidence in him. He was quietly dropped again after a poor performance at Upton Park. Saving penalties against Austrian part timers in pre season is one thing, but Anfield roaring on a new manager with Gerrard and Torres firing bullets at you is another kettle of fish altogether. The last ditch saves at Craven Cottage masked some positional mistakes one would come to expect from a keeper with less than 20 professional appearances behind him. As well as being incredibly inexperienced, I`m not even sure I see a great deal of potential in him.

Wojciech SZCZESNY
The case for: A supremely confident young man with a point to prove. Confidence is an alien trait to Arsenal keepers just now. Szczesny still has praise ringing in his ears from a prosperous loan spell at Brentford and has earned the peculiar distinction of a big reputation amongst supporters having only played for the first team once. Szczesny is whispered to be the great white hope of Arsenal`s goalkeeping future and the reason the manager is only looking for a stop gap in the shape of Schwarzer. The manager has never been afraid to throw in young players with the requisite quality in the past, so it stands to reason he wouldn`t hesitate to hurl a talented 20 year old keeper into the deep end. Szczesny also shows signs of being a commanding, dominant presence unperturbed by making use of his larynx. He is the only option that has a genuinely clean slate in terms of form and confidence of supporters. There may be an element of mistrust between the defence and Mannone; Fabianski and Almunia, but Wojciech is an unknown enough quantity to build trust with the back four without any previous looming overhead.

The case against: His reputation as our goalkeeping saviour mystifies me; he has played one game for us at home to a Championship side. He may have impressed at Brentford, but if I told you we`d just signed MK Dons first choice goalie and that we were going to start with him on Sunday, what would your reaction be? Even if the keeper in question was only 20. Szczesny benefits from the fact that he is simply a.nother other than Almunia or Fabianski. In the few times I have seen him he has shown undeniable quality, but those include a reserve game and Brentford playing at Millwall. Does he yet have the authority to command a defence that has designs on winning the title? In reality, Szczesny probably needs another loan spell, possibly at a Championship/ lower reaches of the Premiership level before he can have designs on the coveted number 1 shirt. Considering his confirmed squad number for the year is again 53, I very much doubt the manager considers him ready yet.

The verdict: Given what we have, I think it`s a no brainer. It has to be Almunia. He may not be the greatest (by no means the worst either) but he`s the best we`ve got. He is well acquainted with occasions such as this and, contrary to popular belief, performs more often than he doesn`t. I`m not going to tell you I think Almunia to be anything other than the fifth or sixth best keeper in the league, but that puts him comfortably above our other options; who are either an accident waiting to happen or too callow. Arsenal seem to like destroying the confidence of young goalkeepers in the last ten years, perhaps we could wait a little while yet before we leave Mannone or Szczesny as gibbering wrecks. Fabianski simply cannot play as it seems at the moment he is making one glaring error in every game; Almunia`s errors are usually a) less glaring and b) more sporadic. In the absence of a new, top class goalie (and Schwarzer would satisfy only one of those qualifiers), I think Almunia has to be the man. What would you do?LD.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Tim Stillman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday August 12 2010

Time: 2:21PM

Your Comments

I agree. Almunia ought to start purely because of his experience and the fact that like it or not, he is probably best equipped to deal with these types of matches. Almunia by some distance should start IMO. He is not as error prone as Fabianski and his confidence is probably a lot better though not great either.
True-Gooner-Blood
Hand on heart LD, I really didn't expect to be going into the opening fixture of the 2010/11 season still having to choose between Almunia or Fabianski. It seems as though AW has buried his head in the sand over this GK issue. You are right, Szczesny does need a loan spell at a good Championship side, or preferably a PL side, within reason. Unfortunately my choice at Anfield goes to Almunia, but only because he makes fewer mistakes than Fabianski. I think you HAVE to agree with me that at this stage, it's a ridiculous position to be in, and one that we never expected.
Cockney Rich
At the end of the film jeepers creepers the monster rips out a young fellas eyes. I would rather play the eyeless kid than Fabianski.
Iceman10
It's got to be Almunia. Ok he is prone to the occasional error, but he doesn't look half as bad as Flappyanski. Big Fat Sam exposed the easiest way to exploit Lukas and it's very effective. Almunia can handle that side of the game much much better and is just as good a shot stopper.
Rocky7
It's a shame because I really saw something in Fabianski, I can see why AW went for him at a young age. But it's going to be one hell of a struggle for him to recover now. I do agree that I fully expected the position to be sorted by now; even if we get Schwarzer it's not an improvement. I have to say I now fully buy into the theory that AW has a real blind spot for keepers. Perhaps he could still call on someone like Seaman or Wilson to help him out because his record in that area is poor.
Little Dutch
I was undecided about Mannone, even after his ' match winning ' performance at Fulham. However, my mind was made up during the home game with Blackburn.
Cockney Rich
I agree about Fabianski LD, I thought he was going to be the next big thing. I do think Schwarzer would be a slight improvement, if only a very small one. But at this stage even a small improvement would be welcome.
Rocky7
Crazy that it hasn't been sorted out by now, Almunia has to start, but Hodgson is a versatile manager who can get his teams to adjust for a range of challenges, the whole world now knows about our lack of confidence at the back, I expect lots of crosses and shots on sight from Liverpool. What is the point in Wenger working hard on our passing game only for all that work to be undone by a cheap goal, he is defeating himself here and then by default the team.
Professor Calculus
I can see us going through a depressing cycle. Almunia plays at Anfield and is at fault for a goal. He makes another howler against Blackpool and suffers a mysterious injury. Fabianski appears at Blackburn and is a bag of nerves making some shocking mistakes. Almunia is back against Bolton but has a bad game. Fabianski's turn now at Sunderland.........and so on and so forth.
Cockney Rich
IMO Fabianski is far too much of a liability to trust in a game of this importance and magnitude. How many chances is AW going to continue to give this guy?
True-Gooner-Blood
Bring back Lukie
shewore
Personally of the four I'd have to vote Almunia as well, but I really wish that there was a better choice. I think that losing Gallas might actually help whomever is back there though. Given how much he was shouting at GK's and trying to be a leader on the defense I can't help but wonder if it was poison for chemistry. That is about the only reason I can see for Wenger to release Gallas when we are so desperate for any center back cover. I'd love to see Friedel come to Arsenal from Villa over Schwarzer, but that doesn't seem likely. I wonder if we could tempt Sparky to let the Aussie go for a few million if we threw one of our 4 gks in on a loan the other way? There are worse places than Fulham to get Szcz or Mannone experience or for Almunia or Fab to rebuild confidence.
Bergkamp4Life
Excellent balanced analysis but it could've been even more complicated if Schwarzer had joined. If anything he'd have been even more likely to feck up than Almunia (but on current form less likely than Fab). It still wouldn't have been an easy pick even with him in the squad. I think we've got to go with Almunia - he played well enough against Celtic and though it was necessary to give Fabianski a run at the tail end of last season in all probability we would have been closer on points to the two teams in front of us had Almunia not been 'ill'. Of course, with the consensus probably opting for Almunia (front page poll for confirmation?) it makes it almost certain that Arsene will go for Fabianski.
Amos.
As much as I would love Szczesny to start on Sunday, the sensible and safest option is to go with Almunia. Alot of goalkeepers are confidence goalkeepers, meaning that if they are playing well, their confidence will be high and therefore leads to good form. If they make mistakes its exactly the opposite and Almunia falls into that category unfortunately.
itsup4grabsnow
Lol Amos. You are right, almost nothing AW does nowadays is about what the consensus would be. If I had to place a bet on the keeper to play against Pool, it would be Fabianski. Wish it is Almunia though.
Deltaforce
It has to be Almunia. While I really would like a top drawer keeper, I don't see Wenger making any moves. In all honesty, barring a genuinely world class keeper coming in, I'd rather Wenger throw some cash at the CB situation. If we get that sorted properly the GK situation won't be as depressing.
smithdj74
Lots of sudden activity on twitter right now from certain journos and Arsenal bloggers, as well as other folks with ties to Arsenal (shareholders, etc) saying that Schwarzer has succeeded in forcing his transfer to Arsenal (after talking to Hughes) and that the deal is moving fast, and firming up. Schwarzer will be in goal at Liverpool for us and Mannone will go on loan to Middlesborough. Arsenal refused to pay Fulham's price and had ended all interest, Fulham did not want to sell, thus forcing MS to act (who really really wants to join us, apparently - at 38 this is his only chance at playing CL football). I don't know if any of this is true, just reporting.
jaelle
This just in: Arsene Wenger is attempting to revolutionize the PL again. He has just announced Arsenal will make the trip to Anfield with no recognized goalkeepers. When questioned by reporters Wenger stated the beautiful game is spoiled by giant men throwing their bodies about and handling the ball. He went on to explain he will be replacing the goalkeeper with a possession oriented passmaster with the objective of maintaining 100% possession in every game. Emmanuel Eboue stood silently smiling and nodding as Wenger spoke. He will allow the CM/Keeper to wear gloves though as he doesn't want them getting blisters while picking the ball out of the back of the net.
smithdj74
Lol! Smithdj74. I do expect Wenger to do the unpopular and field Fabianski, just on the strength of how many pre-season game time he was given. I wouldn't fret much as I think he does appear unperturbed by all the criticism, which is good thing, IMO. Aside from W Szezsessny, he is our most gutsy keeper. One good game and he will be good for us all season (assuming we do not get in a GK before the window closes).
Naijagunner
LOL smithdj74 is killing me. IMO the only benefit that schwarzer brings is renewed confidence from the back 4 and if wenger is simply looking for cover until Szcesny is ready that might turn out to be a good move. It seems wenger doesnt have the same urgency to get us a top quality goalkeeper. The negotiation for CBs was up and running as soon as the season was done there are certainly better optins out there than schwarzer but at the moment I'd happily welcome the guy
anonymous
It's gotta be Almunia over Fabianski every time. However I think Schwarzer is a step up from Almunia, if we can get him. The Aussie seems to command his area better and is less prone to howlers. He's got a strong personality too - in comparison to Almunia whose confidence is fragile - and that's something we really need at the back.
krismon1
We need a goalie who is capable to making saves 90% of the time and forget about the other 10% unsaveable spectecular shots. Making a silly mistake would take at least 10 saves to erase.
dyiu2000
The fact that we’re in this situation bodes very badly for the coming season. The GK position was clearly in need of strengthening and even “goalkeeper adverse” Arsene would have recognised that. There may well have been some negotiations going on behind the scenes that we don’t know about but nevertheless, we should have resolved it by now. At best we can buy in the next couple of weeks and hope the new goalie (and CB) will bed in quickly before dropping too many points as the season starts. Those points could be crucial come May though. Very disappointing.
Sir Henry
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Arsenal Articles

Arsenal Almost But Not Quite There Yet (Saturday September 13 2014)

Wenger Gives Debuchy Injury Update (Saturday September 13 2014)

Stats: Arsenal v Man City (Saturday September 13 2014)

Match Discussion - Man City (h) (Thursday September 11 2014)

Welbeck Closes Arsenal's Transfer Window (Tuesday September 2 2014)

The Transfer Deadline Day Live Blog (Monday September 1 2014)

Archived Arsenal Articles

List All Vital Arsenal Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Amos. 45
2. Naijagunner 35
3. nikolaijns 21
4. Wyn Mills 20
5. FunGunner 18
6. Chippy Brady 16
7. Joe_@** 12
8. damiano_tommassi 11
9. Guyfox 11
10. shewore 8

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Arsenal 2 - 2 Man City
Leicester City 1 - 1 Arsenal
Everton 2 - 2 Arsenal
Arsenal 2 - 1 Crystal Palace

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
4. Southampton 4 2 1 1 5 7
5. Man City 4 2 1 1 3 7
6. Spurs 4 2 1 1 2 7
7. Arsenal 4 1 3 0 1 6
8. Liverpool 4 2 0 2 1 6
9. Man Utd 4 1 2 1 3 5
10. Everton 4 1 2 1 -1 5

Breaking League News

That Killer Instinct!
» Spurs : 15/09/2014 10:25:00
Everton ready for Everton assault
» Everton : 15/09/2014 10:00:00
Palace 0-0 Burnley
» Crystal Palace : 15/09/2014 09:37:00
Lukaku praise following first goal
» Everton : 15/09/2014 09:26:00
Team News: Hull v West Ham
» Hull City : 15/09/2014 08:30:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Who is most likely to end as top scorer this season?
Suggested By:  
Campbell 5%
Giroud 5%
Podolski 5%
Ramsey 10%
Sanchez 33%
Sanogo 2%
Walcott 5%
Welbeck 35%