Arsenal - Arsenal 2 Birmingham City 1
UK time is: 21:17:06
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Arsenal 2 Birmingham City 1

The merciful end of another mind numbing international break was signalled on a day when pretty much everybody I know was at one of two matches. Given that my family has a burgeoning Brummie branch; many eyes were on the Grove yesterday. Meanwhile, a few miles from my home, Crystal Palace were playing Millwall, a match that pretty much splits my immediate social group in half. Pre match drinks saw glasses raised skywards with the news that Rich and Claire are to rear another young Gooner into the world. Support was also shown for Sam Allardyce`s campaign to kick perception out of football. That`s it Fatso, you stick it to the Descartes and Kants ruining our game obsequiously stroking their facial hair and pontificating with their berets and university degrees.

Having endured three disappointing results prior to the international break, the atmosphere was pensive, but the Gunners began well. With Fabregas` spell on the sidelines unexpectedly elongated, it was Wilshere who again picked up the creative baton. He sauntered forward to the edge of Birmingham`s box and exchanged passes with Chamakh; Wilshere drew the Birmingham defence with another disguised pass back to Chamakh, who looked to have the goal winking at him only to see his steered shot expertly blocked by Stephen Carr. The home side thought they had taken the lead after 17 minutes when Carr fouled Chamakh on the left hand side. Nasri swung the free kick in and his compatriot Sebastien Squillaci headed the ball into the roof of the net only to be halted in his celebrations by an errant offside flag. It looked a very generous award to me. The Gunners continued to pile the pressure on and nearly opened their account via the unlikeliest of sources. Nasri`s cross was headed out by Roger Johnson, Sebastien Larsson contrived to have something of a brain fart when he cumbersomely tried to lay the ball back to Carr in his own area, as usual, Clichy was quick to intercept but toe poked the ball centimetres wide of the post.

But a similar story looked set to unfold. Birmingham worked the ball down their left hand side, earning a throw in next to the Arsenal corner flag. The ball was worked back to Keith Fahey; the Blues have a striker that stands at 6 feet 8 inches, which makes Nasri`s complete apathy as he refused to close Fahey down and allowed the Irishman an uninterrupted cross, which Nicola Zigic towered above Djourou to head into the bottom corner. I can`t blame the defence for failing to out jump a player of that size, but it was imperative to stop Birmingham getting crosses to him and Nasri`s lack of awareness gave Chelsea their opening goal at Stamford Bridge when he let Cole in behind him. His paltry effort to shut Fahey down was not good enough. The visitors nearly crept into a shock two goal lead when Stephen Carr floated a free kick to Roger Johnson down the right, he headed the ball down into Arsenal`s six yard area, but serendipitously Zigic and Bowyer rather got in one another`s way and Zigic blasted the ball over.

But Arsenal did claim a deserved and needed equaliser four minutes before half time. I was rather left with the impression that it should have been Diaby sitting in midfield and Wilshere plundering forward. Whilst Diaby is a rangy player with great dribbling technique, his final ball usually has the subtlety and guile of an ice pick. Wilshere has the same dribbling ability and the final ball to boot and he proved it in City`s concession of a penalty. He probed forwards and fed the ball into Chamakh, the ball broke loose in the box and Scott Dann lunged only to find Chamakh had made up the ground and Dann tapped Chamakh`s trailing leg. Chamakh made sure the referee saw it, no question. But Dann didn`t get the ball and impeded Chamakh`s progress in the box. Penalty. Stop whingeing please. Nasri stepped up and steered the ball smartly into the bottom corner with Foster sprawling in the wrong direction. The more penalties you see Nasri take, the more you curse the heavens that he shirked at the Stadium of Light last month. Some needle developed in the game thereafter, Ridgewell kicked Nasri and Nasri retaliated. Nasri was booked, but Ridgewell wasn`t. Atkinson began to look thoroughly out of his depth as tempers flared; Roger Johnson gave Chamakh a quite deliberate whack on the back of the head which Atkinson did not deal with. The half time whistle came at the right time for some players who had lost their heads and for the referee who had lost control of the game.

Arsenal calmed themselves and reasserted their authority on the game, taking the lead four minutes into the second half. Wilshere again plundered forwards and played the ball to Song, Song acrobatically flicked the ball back to Wilshere, who took the ball on his chest before prodding through to Chamakh. It looked as though Carr would clear but he ducked the tackle, presumably tentative that Chamakh would look to exaggerate any sort of contact, Chamakh seized on the loose ball, taking it past Foster before prodding it into the unguarded net. You had the impression that Arsenal would use the goal as a launching pad for a comfortable victory, but two defeats and a gut wrenching last minute equaliser in the last three games had left visible scarring. Time and again Diaby was able to maraud forwards only to be let down by a slow Arsenal attack, leaving him a lack of options. Even when Diaby does have options, he often makes the wrong decision; with nobody in support he was rather hamstrung. The Gunners lacked the incisiveness in the final third to create further chances.

Diaby clipped a right wing cross which was over hit, but Clichy was rapidly onto the loose ball on the left touchline, prodding the ball into Arshavin in the channel, but with Dann at close quarters, he could only toepoke the ball straight at Foster. I know many were left frustrated with Arshavin`s listless performance yesterday, but I think I have more patience with him because I see him taking risks. When his passes weren`t coming off, there were audible groans, but 9 times out of 10, he was inches away from playing a team mate through on goal. However, Andrey, if you`re reading, please, please, please stop trying those stupid back heels. They`re not working. Nerves became frayed as the end of the game approached and Lukasz Fabianski was decisive in dealing with some Birmingham set pieces. In injury time, Wilshere blotted his copy book of an otherwise excellent display when he was sent off. He miscontrolled Song`s pass and lunged into a tackle which caught Zigic on the ankle. A reckless challenge that got the red card it deserved. I know a great many observers will be salivating over the challenge, they wilfully miss the point. Arsenal supporters and their manager have simply asked that the rules are applied when people tackle recklessly. On this occasion, it was.

Alex McLeish tried to use the incident as a plateau to park his soapbox on, bizarrely bemoaning the fallout of the Eduardo incident and what it had put Birmingham through. Yeah, sorry about what we put you through there Alex. You don`t have to do much research to discover that Wenger has spoken for the game of football and not just his own players when speaking out on bad tackling. In the wake of the Sunderland game, he said; "'I do not say I get an unfair press, it`s not about me this story, it`s about the players who play football with the right intention. Don't take me wrong we make as well sometimes bad fouls and I have the same responsibility than you.' Manager and player admitted liability here without resorting to the "he isn`t that sort of player and loves his mum" rubbish. Birmingham pushed in the final minutes; a game of head tennis broke out when Scott Dann looped a header dangerously into the area but Fabianski was brave and decisive in collecting the ball. It was enough to hold out for the final whistle, but I was still left frustrated with some of our players in the final minutes. Bendtner`s ill advised attempted flick, Song idiotically trying to take three touches in his own area in injury time when he should have put his foot through the ball. Refusal to do these sorts of rudimentary tasks has cost us points before and, I fear, will again because I don`t think we have learned. However, at this point, cold hard analysis is for another day. What was important was the win, we got it and we deserved it, that`s all that really matters. We lacked sharpness in the final third, but with this win under our belts and players returning, let`s hope that returns.LD.

21.FABIANSKI, 27.EBOUE, 18.SQUILLACI(c), 20.DJOUROU, 22.CLICHY, 17.SONG, 2.DIABY, 19.WILSHERE, 8.NASRI, 23.ARSHAVIN (7.Rosicky `70), 29.CHAMAKH (52.Bendtner `79). Unused: 11.Vela, 14.Walcott, 15.Denilson, 28.Gibbs, 53.Szczesny.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Tim Stillman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday October 17 2010

Time: 3:25PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Good stuff and, both good and bad, that was about the size of it. The 3 points were important and we played as though they were. Another game in which Fabianski didn't do himself any harm. We may well see him holding his place for a while. The longer he does so the better it will be for the clubs confidence in both our keepers because Almunia will always be able to do a job for us. If Fabianski can show he can do it better then so much the better for us.
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 15:56:00

I meant to include in my report that that was one of our post match conversations, do we stick with Fabianski? A run of games seems to have done his confidence the world of good and maybe he should stay and build that up for his and our long term good. I still think one of Wenger's biggest errors as our manager was dithcing Manninger in 98, he should have stayed at least until he made a mistake. I'd be inclined to stick with Fabianski for now.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 16:00:00

I think part of the exasperation with Arshavin is that he's one of our big players that you expect to be winning these kinds of games for us. If anything, he places with an nonchalance that's unmerited given our position and his contribution. We also seem to have lost our ability to counter-attack efficiently as we did in days gone by. And it does appear that we want to score the perfect goal almost every time. As you say, this team hasn't learned and we're likely to be punished in games to come, meaning the season won't be any different from the last few. I apologise for the pessimism!
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 16:02:00

Sorry, should read "if anything, he plays with an nonchalance..."
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 16:03:00

You could sense there were nerves, arguably more so at 2-1 than 1-0 down. They know that they can't afford to throw away another lead. I thought Diaby was excellent, barring, as you point out, the final ball. But I think that is linked intrinsically to these nerves. Because none of our midfielders want to sit and anchor on the halfway line (like Mikel does for Chelsea), if a defence-splitting pass doesn't come off, we are extremely vulnerable if the opposition wants to counter. I assume that's the reason Diaby was always passing sideways on the edge of the area, to slow it down and make sure we're in total control. Well, either that or his decision making in the final third is just *****. But I think that'll give them confidence, and they can express themselves more now they are back to winning ways. Agree about Arshavin. He tried 3 of those backheels in about five minutes. If the first doesn't come off, DON'T try it again immediately after! Djourou had as good a game as I've seen of him, as did Chamakh; taking the shoves, elbows and abuse 'like a man'. He could have easily petulantly lashed out like Nasri did but kept his head. Can't express how pleased I am with him. What a signing he's been. Never thought I'd say this, but I beg that Wenger keeps Fabianski between the sticks. That's three solid performances on the bounce and he will be high on morale. I really don't fancy a confidence-stricken Almunia against Carlos Tevez, thanks. LD, I noticed towards the end of the first half there seemed to be some friction between McLeish and the fans but I couldn't really see. Any idea what happened? Good write-up as always.
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 16:10:00

Arshavin's contribution has been very good this season, in terms of chances he creates and goals he's scored. He can look frustrating because he tries to make the difference. I think his contribution has been in excess of Nasri's this year, who I still think is playing too safely. But Arshavin definitely had a bad game yesterday. The attacking player who seems to be combining Arshavin's adventure and Nasri's economy is Rosicky. He has to be playing at the moment for me.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 16:13:00

I wasn't aware of anything between the supporters and McLeish, I sit on the other side of the stadium.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 16:14:00

I think we've got to stick with Fabianski, otherwise we're just going to keep going round in circles until either one of them decides they've had enough and leaves or we sign a better keeper. That panalty save in the CL seems to have inspired him, he's playing well and deserves his place.
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 16:28:00

Mr loverman CHAMAKH!
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 17:01:00

Tough game coming up on Tuesday, we're going to have to play well to win it... Saturday was ok, but as you rightly say LD the scars from the last 3 fixtures were visible, in players and crowd. Let's hope Cesc is back for City away next weekend, I'm not sure i can take Diaby playing in that position for much longer
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 18:03:00

Good point on Nasri and the conceded goal. Our defence and goalie get a lot of stick, but the mid field really need to up the defensive side to their game. Also, we needed someone who was not afraid to take a shot on goal, esp with the Brum area so crowded, and so little space to work intimate passing moves. I only saw Rosicky doing that. The team really needs to think more practically in situations like that.
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 21:12:00

As for the goalie debate, I think Fabianski has done enough to keep his place. But it is a testament to the desperate times when gooners are happy with a performance that is expected from a premier league keeper. He didnt do anything special, but was certainly solid. I found myself applauding a couple of routine punches by Fabianski. Let's hope he carries on from here.
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 21:15:00

Bootoo - lol!
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 21:35:00

I just watched the Zigic goal five times in a row and Nasri was jogging slowly towards Fahey and I am convinced even if he had broken his neck trying to stop the cross coming he still would have been short. The problem wasn't really Nasri's apathy it was more of a positional problem; Diaby was dragged to the throw by his man Hleb. Nasri was in the right back position closing down Ridgewell but this mix up led Fahey in acres of space and the cross resulted in the goal. Otherwise a pretty great match-report.
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 21:56:00

Well rounded reporting and fair reflection of the happenings and players' assessments, LD. Arshavin tries too hard to make something happen but only succeeds in muddling things up. He is however, always in dangerous positions but could do with a few substitute appearances, for Rosicky. Diaby can be tedious with his final ball, it is amazing, even when the obvious pass is right there in his face. While he "was let down by a slow Arsenal attack" a couple of times, there were many more times where he slowed perfect counter attacking opportunities, inexplicably, depriving us of scoring possibilities. He is a skillful player and few can keep hold of the ball as well as he, but he must be just that bit more decisive at the edge of the opponent's box; playing for France, you will be nonplussed at the number of shots he takes and can only wonder if it is his instruction not to shoot at this club or the defensive approach of the opposition affects him. It pleases me to say Fabianski has earned the right to keep the shirt; Wenger only has to come up with a good story as he will soon run out of his usual "diplomatic illnesses" to explain Almunia's absence. I think the Pole is a confident young man and as it is with the position of Keeper, can only get better when the responsibility is entrusted to him on a full time basis. Happy with this win, even if I thought we should have gone for more goals.
Report Abuse
17/10/2010 22:13:00

Diaby was so frustrating, so many times i said out-loud "oh well done" as i edged further forward on my seat only to be let down when he got outside the box, and i've never noticed before that game, but he's soooooo very slow to shoot, i think he had 3 shots in that game and they all got closed down and blocked because you can see his lanky legs swining at it a mile off, maybe it's his height? I dunno, but if you watch Nasri or Arshavin shoot they probably take half the time.
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 00:50:00

I agree with LD on Arshavin, and think that he cops a bit of unfair flack, cos for all his defensive laziness, it has been Nasri who has been the culpable one for goals conceded this season.
Ozi Gooner
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 02:00:00

Anyone think that the groans from the home support have inhibited our players? Passes in the final third are inherently risky and having 60,000+ people on top of you for misplacing a pass seems to have made Diaby & Nasri ultra-cautious over the last few seasons . Contrast this with an experienced pro like Arshavin who seems impervious to the crowd and has no qualms attempting 3 backheels in the space of 5 minutes because he knows that only 1 needs to be right for a goal to be scored.
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 04:42:00

I dunno sunaadh - It's no new thing for our fans to moan clearly audible groans to the players for bad passes and such.
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 10:03:00

Grone - Just saw a highlight of that goal, and yeah, Nasri would never have gotten to the player in time. There's no point in wasting energy on something that's never going to happen. It wasn't an extended highlight, so whether Nasri could have done better positionally I don't know.
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 11:24:00

But had Nasri at least made an attempt to get towards the player, he could have hurried him, put him off the delivery, put some doubt into Fahey's mind. Fahey receives the ball and is ready to do something instantly, then Nasri visibly gives up and Fahey is able to relax, take his time and pick out an inch perfect cross. One can only speculate as to how much good it would have done, but it's tangible evidence that our midfielders don't have that, "at all costs" mentality. Put it this way, had Nasri been in a race with Fahey at the other end of the pitch in which Fahey is a few yards ahead, I bet Nasri doesn't shrug his shoulders and give up the chase straight away.
Little Dutch
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 11:54:00

I think we'll have to agree to disagree on this one, I don't think he would have paniced or rushed it at all, Sami was miles away, even Linford Christie wouldn't have worried him in my opinion. That's the beauty of football though, we all see things differently.
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 12:04:00

Nasri has definitely had an excellent season to date, but I agree with you twofold LD. His lack of defensive nous is at times frustrating, and he spends far too much time on the ball rather than looking for that incisive pass. This is what sets Arshavin apart from Nasri, Arsharvin more likely to provide that telling moment. But, I think you need both types for players in a side; Arshavin does lose possession an awful lot, and rarely wins it back. I believe it is only Nasri's goals and fitness worries that are keeping him ahead of an otherwise brilliant Rosicky. The Diaby/Wilshire dynamic is interesting. I understand why Wilshere was sitting deeper, his harrying in defense and range of passing is far better than Diaby. But, despite all the beautiful dribbling (which at times takes my breath away), Diaby provides very little in an attacking sense. They needed to be rotating between defensive and offensive duties, but given that they have not played a lot together, that can be forgiven. Did someone say getting three points when you are playing badly is a sign of a championship contender? whisper it quietly...
Report Abuse
18/10/2010 12:49:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Arsenal Articles

Infographic - Most Fouled....Sánchez (Wednesday November 25 2015)

Stats: Arsenal v Dinamo Zagreb (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Match Preview Arsenal vs Zagreb (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Archived Arsenal Articles

List All Vital Arsenal Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Naijagunner 25
2. Galway Gooner 18
3. 0716389009 14
4. Wyn Mills 6
5. Afcdc 4
6. Guyfox 2
7. phreddy 2
8. Nwankwo25 2
9. Pat Rick 1
10. Will-i-am10 1

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Leicester City 13 8 4 1 8 28
2. Man Utd 13 8 3 2 10 27
3. Man City 13 8 2 3 14 26
4. Arsenal 13 8 2 3 12 26
5. Spurs 13 6 6 1 13 24
6. West Ham 13 6 3 4 4 21
7. Everton 13 5 5 3 8 20

Arsenal Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Buzz on the Spot - Juventus v City - The aftermath
» Man City : 26/11/2015 20:45:00
Pellegrini & Toure On Juventus Loss
» Man City : 26/11/2015 20:36:00
Ulloa Talks Manchester United
» Leicester City : 26/11/2015 19:35:01
Davis Extends Fleetwood Spell
» Leicester City : 26/11/2015 19:30:01
Vardy On Practice Making Perfect
» Leicester City : 26/11/2015 19:27:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

MOTM vs Dinamo Zagreb
Suggested By:  
Cech 6%
Bellerin 0%
Kos 0%
BFG 0%
Monreal 3%
Flamini 0%
Cazorla 0%
Campbell 3%
Ozil 59%
Sanchez 29%
Giroud 0%
Debuchy 0%
Rambo 0%
Chambers 0%