Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

The 'we' and the 'anybody else'

The 'we' and the 'anybody else'

A good few years back working with the Sales Director of a company based in the City of London I'd sat in on a sales review meeting that he'd chaired. He'd warned me beforehand that he was unlikely to get anything useful himself from it as most of those there would just see it as an opportunity to voice their grievances. The sales staff would have spent all month being told by their clients that their prices are too high, service not as good as their competitors and that their products were poor he mused. I already knew that they were the best performing company in their sector on a number of different criteria but other companies had bigger market share even if in some cases they were making a loss and wouldn't be able to sustain that position indefinitely. That didn't count much for the sales people who felt they weren't maximising their commission because others were pursuing desperate policies of predatory pricing and uncosted service. Most were concerned about their next month's pay packet not what it could be next year or how long it could be sustained. 'We'll spend 45 minutes having to listen to them whine and moan and 15 minutes getting them to focus on the strengths which has brought us the success we do have' the SD told me.

He made a great performance of taking his watch off, pretending to wind it up and laid it out on the meeting table directly in front of him so that everyone knew he was keeping a close watch on the time. Make it count he was signalling. After listening for 45 minutes to all the failings they'd been told by clients that they were compromised by he asked them all individually to name 2 or 3 reasons why, given that things were so bad, people were buying from them at all - after all it wasn't as though sales weren't good - just that there was more to be had. At the end of 15 minutes he'd got from them at least a dozen good reasons which he put up on the white board behind him as to why the company's offer was really quite strong and the sales guys left reassured by the realisation that as they reflected on their strengths they were a pretty good company with some genuinely strong positives after all. They'll be back next month whining and moaning just as strongly the SD told me knowing that he would have to find a way of picking them up all over again.

When things are going well football supporters are fed all sorts of wonderful nonsense about their team, of their superiority, their managerial and tactical genius that their players are true world beaters full of winning mentality who will dominate the game for years. Success can be measured in relative terms and a team achieving 4th place for the first time in an age will be fed the same bullshit that another winning a trophy might expect. If the team is good enough to win a trophy, but not successful in doing so, as expectations fail to be met supporters are fed the same exaggerated guff by the media and opinion formers that the sales staff of the City firm were fed by their customers. Elements of truth are magnified to give the impression that things are irredeemably poor and that total breakdown and failure are inevitable. In consequence we get absurd levels of overreaction with blog posts pronouncing this as the worst season ever experienced and groups of disaffected fans setting up campaigns demanding that some uninformed action be taken to save us from hell and damnation.

Unlike the sales meeting though the internet allows 24/7 discourse to take place and it can't be influenced with anything like the control the SD was able to bring. There is no wrist watch to limit the time spent moaning and allow for rational reflection so for much of the time supporters have only the sound of their own frustration and the scorn of their rivals to feed their thoughts. As positive as free speech is invariably the spiral of depression continues to be fed by its own volume.

But there's a gaping hole in this analogy. The fatal flaw is in the suggestion that supporters are really as much a part of the team as the City firm's sales force was. When Wenger was asked whether the crowd, some of whom had made vocal their dissatisfaction after the Blackburn game, would stick with the team subliminally rather than consciously he drew a distinction between 'we' (the club and team) and 'anybody else' (the crowd).

'That is not our concern, we are responsible for our performances and for our attitude, not for the attitude of anybody else' he responded.

It's an indication of just how much supporters, and it's true of support among all PL teams (lest some of the hypersensitive tendency here see this as a criticism of our support and not just a regret) are being viewed as an audience, more that of a customer and not an integral part of the club as Wenger perhaps unwittingly acknowledged.

When Sky began the process of commoditising football in 1992, encouraging those like Abramovich to distort the sport even further a decade later (what would competition authorities make of any business selling a product at least 40% below the cost of production as Chelsea have done?) they also brought about a gradual change in the relationship between clubs and the basis of its support. Now when a supporter claims that he is not being adequately rewarded for high ticket prices or demands that a minimum amount be spent on transfers he is acting in much the same way that any customer might demand quicker delivery times or an increase in promotional spend in return for his patronage. Those insisting that if nothing is done then support will dwindle away are accepting that supporters will inevitably act as any other customer unhappy with their product would.

In the two decades since Sky bought into the game a whole generation of supporters perhaps now heading towards or into their 30's, and those since, have grown up knowing football more as a commodity. Most would baulk at the suggestion that they are becoming customers preferring to still see themselves as supporters of the faith, keepers of the flame, a genuine part of a club but the reality is slowly, inexorably and against their real instincts supporters are becoming that little bit more detached from the club they support. Hopes and aspirations are being replaced by entitlement and expectations as supporters themselves are becoming complicit in their own divorce while football tries to maintain the pretence for as long as possible that its supporters are anything other than customers. Much has changed about football in the last 20 years.

Join The Vital Debate

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Monday April 4 2011
Time: 12:00PM


It's a very pertinent analogy in that one of the guys I have a season ticket with insists upon describing the more disaffected members of our support as "the consumers." I understand some of the disaffection, even if I don't relate to all of it. But I was speaking with some people the other day and commenting how sad it is that football support has been reduced to numbers on a screen. Transfer monies spent, trophies won. These things are important, I'm not dismissing that. But though football supporters have always have exorcised their right to vent (and it is a right), maybe I'm just being nostalgic, but I'm sure it used to be a lot more fun than this? People used to go to football for entertainment as well didn't they? The bonding experience, the atmosphere? Feeling that a club is a part of the community? All these things seem to have dribbled away from a lot of people and I'm a bit weary of having to explain to people that they are still important to me.
Little Dutch
04/04/2011 12:16:00
When you pay what we do we are entitled to voice our dissatisfaction, whether the club or other fans don't like that, tough. As for entitlement, I have never believed we are entitled to anything unreasonable...
04/04/2011 12:20:00
100% in agreement with all of that LD. Does the fact that we haven't won the CL make that night against Barca at the Emirates recently less thrilling? Has there really been no joy in a season in which with a few weeks to go we're still in with a slim chance of the title? The single most attractive thing to me is feeling part of the club and sharing the highs and lows with others yet so many seem determined to divorce or allow themselves to be divorced from the club and see it as something to be opposed. Sure there's plenty to complain about - that's part of the attraction too no matter how much or how little you pay - but paying for it should just make you more determined to enjoy the entertainment - it's the ride I'm paying for not the necessarily the destination.
04/04/2011 12:33:00
LD - maybe (probably) it's part and parcel of the everything that's changed in the game, from Sky to all-seater stadium to the internet. Going to football when you were able to stand in terraces in a throng of people and really support your team was a totally different experience to what we have now. I don't go to away games, so am only talking about our home ground. I don't see the game in its current state in the PL as being sustainable. If the only way to win trophies is by spending money, then the game is over. I don't know the German model intimately, but I hear it's better than ours and their teams still compete in the CL. Not holding my breath for the FA or PL to change things though.
04/04/2011 12:36:00
Arsenal are more responsible than any fan for making the club feel less a part of the community and treating fans as commodities. Arsenal are also one of the main culprits in embracing the money, money, money modern attitude of clubs, it just so happens they are not quite as good as Utd and many other clubs at doing it.
04/04/2011 12:37:00
It's true that football is reaping what it has sown. Not true that Arsenal are any more culpable than any other club any more than it is true that it is only Arsenal fans who see themselves as, and behave as consumers.
04/04/2011 12:52:00
Yes true Arsenal are more culpable than most, you said we are one of the biggest clubs in the world, how do you think we got that way Amos and a club like Nottingham Forest didn't?
04/04/2011 13:05:00
I think Arsenal are pretty good at giving back to the community to an extent, Islington benefits a fair amount both financially and through other schemes, you could argue the working class inhabitants of the borough (of which there are more than Upper St frequenters would like to admit/know of) have been priced out of going. But I'd say AFC give more than say, a certain club up the SS determined to leave their borough. Feeling disenfranchised is something i've felt for about a good 5/6 years now, my first real memories was when in about 92 when I was 6/7, so Sky is all i've known. The reason for me feeling this disenfranchised is down to players acting more and more detached from what I can relate to, imagine having to go out for a pint with Adebayor or Cole? It's money and being thick berk hunts that's done that to them.
04/04/2011 13:05:00
Well Cloughy got em relegated, and they've suffered through not being towards the top over the sky years.
04/04/2011 13:06:00
Ok then, Everton. True to say they haven't embraced the commercial, sky, money side of the game as well as Arsenal?
04/04/2011 13:09:00
Page 1/7
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7

Login to post a comment

Best of International Football News

Recent Arsenal Articles

One Transfer Deadline Was Never Enough Was It

You've got to love the football authorities, if transfer deadline days weren't ridiculous enough already - they've now begun to breed.

A Closer Look At The Arsenal Injury List

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Arsenal FC and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

Wilshere & Chambers On Disappointing Defeat

Jack Wilshere and Calum Chambers have reflected on a very poor performance from Arsenal as we hosted Ostersunds for the Europa League second leg at the Emirates on Thursday.

AC Milan Next Up For Arsenal

In the draw Round of 16 draw earlier today, Arsenal have been paired with AC Milan in the next round of the Europa League.

Arsenal Archived Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Arsenal
Write For Vital Arsenal
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

EL - Ostersunds MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Xhaka0%
Sub - Willock0%
Sub - Nelson8%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Arsenal Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Galway Gooner2
The Vital Football Members League