UK time is: 23:19:45
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

2010-11 Player by Player- Part 1

With the dust gently settling on the window sill of 2010-11, it`s time to look back at some of the recriminations and the retrospective glories. It`s been one of the more topsy turvy campaigns I can remember as an Arsenal fan; for every Barcelona and Chelsea, there was a Spurs at home and a Birmingham Cup Final. Whilst the season must ultimately be viewed as a failure given our position in late February, it`s perhaps worth while rating individuals` contribution, or lack thereof, to the colourful kaleidoscope that was 2010-11.

1. Manuel ALMUNIA- The season could not be rightly argued as anything other than an unmitigated disaster for the hapless Spanish keeper. His skill set is not quite the perpetual disaster area some would have you believe- though not of adequate quality to represent a supposedly title chasing side. But playing for Arsenal is about a little bit more than quality. When Almunia has made mistakes, much like Manninger and Senderos before him- he has allowed them to haunt him and guide his every action thereafter. His Arsenal career appears to have been littered with a series of convenient injuries, which suggest he needs cosseting and protecting from the glare. Compare to Szczesny whose last minute bungle at Wembley lost us a Cup Final. His reaction has been to entirely forget about it. Almunia`s season will be remembered for a fumble against West Brom (mitigated perhaps by an elbow injury) and the last significant act of his Arsenal career was to go walkies at the edge of the Hawthorns penalty area. He looks like a man who has wanted this nightmare to end since last August. I don`t think he`ll have to wait much longer. 4 out of 10.

2. Abou DIABY- Perhaps the best summation of his season can be made in April. Against Blackpool, Liverpool and for the first half against Spurs, he was arguably the best player on the pitch. Then he got injured. Again. Against Fulham his prompting midfield play created van Persie`s goal, but by then it was too late. Michael Essien`s assault on an already terminally damaged ankle saw him sit most of the season out injured. Every time he came back, a muscle niggle sent him packing swiftly back to the medical room. The nadir of his season of course will be viewed as the idiotic red card against Newcastle (though the temptation to slap Joey Barton must be very real). There again, we were 4-0 up, you don`t expect a red card to hurt you quite so much when four goals clear in the second half. You`ve the feeling there`s a good player there somewhere, but I fear Dan Smith`s horrific lunge put paid to a promising career before it had really begun. 5

3. Bacary SAGNA- In a season that has fluctuated in ups and downs, Sagna has been something of a constant. Constantly fit, constantly playing, constantly performing. One of Arsenal`s stand out performers and one of the mainstays you would back not to explode like a Chinese firework when the pressure level rises. His crossing, a notable weakness in his game when he first arrived, has improved to the point that, slowly, everybody`s started to catch on. Even with his left foot, Banger can deliver a mean cross. In a team defined by its flakiness and inconsistency, Sagna has been as solid as a rock and one of the season`s huge bright points. 8.5

4. Cesc FABREGAS- Another season ravaged by muscle injuries, the toll of annual international tournaments and huge club demands have wreaked havoc with a season that has, nevertheless, still delivered so much. An assist every 171.6 minutes played this season give you all the evidence you need that Cesc is the utmost creative force in the Premier League. Without him, Arsenal look bereft of ideas. With him, the players rather give you the impression that they cower in his shadow- happy to pass him the ball then run and hide in a corner. Many have questioned his leadership skills which I think to be incredibly unfair. The point is he`s probably one of only two leaders (three if you count Vermaelen) we have. The manager made some pointed comments that the burden- and Cesc`s unflinching willingness to take it on- have been too much for him this season. I didn`t take that as a criticism of Cesc, more a criticism of his team mates who have allowed him to try and struggle with that burden. As Shay Given will tell you, you usually find your reputation is enhanced when you don`t take any risks, don`t try to do anything commanding and therefore, don`t fail. Fabregas has the potent combination of talent and a winner`s desire. To lose him would leave us reeling. 8

5. Thomas VERMAELEN- One of the season`s big "what ifs?" Having only played 5 games this season, it`s impossible to rate his contribution. But one can only wonder whether Arsenal`s vulnerability to set pieces would have been quite so pronounced with his organisational skills and physicality. He wasn`t as perfect last season as some would have you believe- he suffered maulings at the hands of Rooney and Drogba owing to a proclivity to get too tight to his markers. But it would have been interesting to see how he would have learned and adapted in his second season. "Thomas Vermaelen, we`ve missed him all year" came the cry at Craven Cottage. I`m inclined to agree.

6. Laurent KOSCIELNY- It`s been an odd season for Koscielny. Man of the match performances against Barcelona and Manchester United at home, no player has clocked up more minutes this season. That`s quite some baptism of fire for somebody that was plying his trade in Ligue 1`s mid table this time last year. On the other hand, he has given away, by my count, five penalties and been red carded twice. There was also the devastating mix up between he and Szczesny in the Carling Cup Final. However, I have been impressed by the raw materials of Koscielny. The manager said he was a broken man after the Carling Cup Final, but that did not translate into any of his performances. He strikes me as a guy that stands up to be counted and that`s a very desirable quality in a Premier League centre half. Koscielny has elevated the level at which he is playing twice in quick succession, which gives one the impression he`s a quick learner. A solid season this year, I`ve a feeling that he`ll have an excellent season next year. 7.5

7. Tomas ROSICKY- The season began promisingly enough for Rosicky; a mature player admittedly happy to be a squad member, he turned in some impressive displays in the early season- even bagging himself my August Player of the Month award. Rosicky`s charms have become more subtle, dropped into central midfield as the probing, passing sort that keeps the ball ticking over in the opposition half and makes the team play. Much like the role Modric has performed with such distinction for Spurs this season. However, as the season drew on, his charms became too subtle. His passing lacks the penetration it used to and having registered one goal in 18 months, he simply does not offer enough impact in the final third for the position he plays. Since February, he has been a ghost in the Arsenal squad, which suggests he isn`t longed for North London any longer. A same, a good player there, but one that has probably been forever lost to injury. 6

8. Samir NASRI- Much like the team themselves, a promising start that rather tailed off. Had the votes been cast in January, Nasri would likely have been crowned PFA Player of the Year. His previously intricate play had begun to pack a punch as he found the ability to burst beyond his centre forward and into the opposing penalty area. Witness his give and go with Fabregas for the goal at Manchester City; the threshold of his campaign with two beautifully crafted goals against Fulham. Each an exhibition of poise and technique in the area. A quick brain and quick feet. At St. Andrews on New Year`s Day, he and Fabregas might as well have been playing with their own ball. It was like watching Henry and Pires in their pomp. Nasri had become a genuine match winner. However, with Cesc not in the side, Nasri`s play lacked the same punch. As the season unfolded, Nasri was overshadowed by a fit again Robin van Persie. You get the impression Nasri has another small leap to make before he can claim to be one of Arsenal`s true indispensables, but nevertheless he`s made a massive leap towards that status this season. Working on the assumption of a 9 for the first half of the season and a 7 for the second half. 8

10. Robin van PERSIE- 21 goals in 22 games. A goal every 97 minutes- a comfortably better ratio than Golden Boot winners Dimitar Berbatov and Carlos Tevez. Goals in his last 9 consecutive away matches- a record and one that could yet continue. What more do you really want me to say? An injury robbed us of his services for the first three months of the season and even for six weeks or so after his comeback, he was managed with kid gloves and used sparingly. Since New Year`s Day, van Persie`s form has been unmatched. Right foot, left foot, headed goals (remember his towering header at St. James Park), conjured on his lonesome, latching onto through balls, poachers goals in crowded penalty boxes. He does the lot. Perhaps the only irony is that his free kick taking appears to have nose dived. But if Nasri was Arsenal`s foremost player for the first half of the season, van Persie was without peer for the second half. The interesting point though maybe how van Persie`s game might be effected if we revert to 4-4-2 next season? Van Persie has yet to strike up a convincing strike partnership in his whole career to date. 8.5

11. Carlos VELA- Started the season fairly promisingly, with goals from the bench against Blackpool, Braga and Bolton. However, with Chamakh in fine form in the early part of the season, Vela simply couldn`t get any game time. There appeared to be something of a stand off with the manager when it was decided he would go out on loan in January, with Vela preferring to go to Spain, whilst Wenger wanted him to prove himself in England. Then there was an unseemly piece of attempted profiteering from his agent that put the kibosh on a loan spell with Bolton. They got Daniel Sturridge instead and, it has to be said, they got the fatter end of the wedge there. Vela didn`t make the Baggies 18 for their last two games of the season. Which all but confirms his Arsenal career is finished. Hell of a lot of ability, but he doesn`t strike me as the type with the hunger to reach the levels of the game he could. Shame. 5

14. Theo WALCOTT- A markedly improved season for Theo, who has found consistency at last. 13 goals is a none too shabby reminder of how clinical a finisher he has become. Peeling off of the right flank, swerving his runs to perfection, Walcott`s very presence shifts an opposing defence back ten yards. For evidence, review Barcelona`s Maxwell staying pretty much camped on the edge of his own area, his shorts a foul shade of brown at the prospect of Walcott leaving him for dead. Perfunctory areas of his game, such as his ball control and his passing which were previously erratic, have been refined and his tendency to fade out of games is slowly deserting him. However, there is still room for improvement- he still gives a rabbit in the headlights impression at times. I don`t ever recall seeing an Arsenal player looking as scared in a match as I saw Theo at Stoke. His crossing still requires some work too; he still occasionally just lashes a ball in without looking. But the bottom line is that, when Theo is fit, Andrey Arshavin sits on the bench. That`s clear progress in a nutshell. 8

15. DENILSON Pereira de Neves- A season of regression for the Brazilian. The return to fitness of Aaron Ramsey, the emergence of Jack Wilshere and the consistency of Song have left Denilson feeling the distinct chill of shadow at London Colney. I don`t particularly think the 4-3-3 system has suited his qualities either; a 3 man midfield leaves our midfield trio with more ground to cover and I don`t think Denilson has had the stamina to perform that function since his back injury. Lack of playing time really hurts a player when they hit 22 or 23 and we`ve seen that in Denilson this season. He was hauled off at half time at the Hawthorns and never seen again. Judging by his recent comments, that was to be his swansong. 5

Part 2 coming soon. Don`t forget to vote for your Player of the Season in the poll at the bottom right of the page. I will do a write up on your winner- whoever it be.LD.

Follow me on twitter @LittleDutchVA




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Tim Stillman Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Friday May 27 2011

Time: 10:43AM

Your Comments

Can't seem to make the bold font work.
Little Dutch
Very objective and fair ratings in my view. Considering the injuries and lower playing time for Cesc this season maybe a rating of 7.5 would suffice. RvP may have got a 9 if he had played more games and a 10 if all his shots which hit the woodwork had gone in!
Deltaforce
A 21 goal season is excellent for a player who has played for the entire season. For a player who's played only 22 games is astonishing. Fortunately for us Rob doesn't appear to be like Cesc or Nasri, he's happy at Arsenal, and we're happy to have him. The dude is deadly!
Rocky7
I do wish sometimes that Cesc will see how the team he is so eager to join are full of complete cocks and how they have been completely disrespectful of the club he claims to care about.
Dberg
Regarding Cesc - any chance at all that he will be around come next season? We will be reeling , alright. but we got to prepared for it.
Sajit
If Barca don't cough up a serious offer Sajit then yes there is every chance. We would just never sell him to citeh, we aren't a feeder club like sp*rs, and he would never go to Real. Nasri is just been told by his agent to hold out for the maximum and based on his season we shouldn't quibble unless his demands are utterly ridiculous in which case thanks and bye.
nikolaijns
Someone needs to pass on the message to Velas' agent that his Arsenal career is over then as he seems to be under a different impression? http://www.thegunninghawk.com/2011/05/27/carlos-velas-agent-many-rumours-but-arsenal-want-him-back-for-pre-season/
nikolaijns
Wenger couldn't work his magic with Almunia. He just didn't have enough character. Same for Vela and Denilson. Nasri's demands should be met. We are too eager to please and hand contracts to young kids when we should take care of business first. Believe me, Nasri can become a world beater. just motivate it. The reason Theo takes arshavin's spot is because Arshavin has regressed. The 2 players are uncomparable.
Gael-Force
Niko, funny how agents always play the opposite card. When a club wants to sell a player the agent says 'No he wants to stay'. When the club wants to keep the player its 'He needs greater challenges'.... Vela will be hard to shift. His value has gone down and i suspect he's on too high a salary for the clubs wanting him.
Gael-Force
I think Vela ought to be given a chance. Tbf he hasn't had a decent run of games at Arsenal or even at West Brom. And when he did play for West Brom he scored two vital goals for them which were crucial in their survival. I think Vela is a player that will only get better if he gets many more games. At the moment he looks like a stranger to the English game. He looks to be much more suited to Spain or Italy. But having said that if he gets a run of games and really starts performing then there is no doubt he could become a really really quality player.
Eboue=GOD
van Persie is fast becoming a complete striker. As you pointed out LD right foot, left foot, heading. It's all there. Best central striker in the world right now. And we only spent 1.25 million for him. 50 million for Torres. What a waste of money.
Eboue=GOD
Vela is utterly infuriating and really the poster boy for Wengerball III. All the talent in the world but the application of someone having a sunday kickabout with a few mates, the constant grinning suggests it's all a bit of a playboy lark and he can retire to his parents mansion in Beverley Hills if it stops being fun. The briefest of shows and a couple of goals for WBA still don't suggest to me he's anywhere near ready to be around an Arsenal 1st team. Just still has the trademark inconsistency shown by too many of our squad and all too often puts on the cloak of invisibility that a few of them seemed to have purchased a job lot of (sup Theo?) Another year on loan and if he's serious about a future with us then it has to be at a premier league club, ideally 5h1kicking glamour free merchants like wolves or Bolton that will wilshere him up. Then come back wipe the perpetual grin of yer face and show us what you have to offer.
nikolaijns
It is unlikely but if Vela is to be kept on, he will do well to resign himself to life on the bench. Wenger can make him up into an impact sub, then gradually ease him into the first team. The lad's got talent and surely, there is greatness somewhere in there.
Naijagunner
Good ratings - it'll be a shame to see Rosicky go, just because of his battle back from injury. However, you're right, the time has come for Wenger's Old Yellow moment.
deaduncleted
our players' individual efforts are not being centered on our team's success.. We have to invest in the market and bring some quality players who can teach consistency to our players and who can change a game on their own(change being not from a winning side to a losing side) there are lots of players like that out there in the market..
The Verminator
We've just put a stop to Vela going to the copa america too so doesn't look like he's offski, unless it's to prevent an injury that would hamper a sale? http://www.thegunninghawk.com/2011/05/29/arsenal-block-carlos-vela-no-permission-to-play-copa-america/
nikolaijns
Nico, was he even picked by his Country for that tournament?
Naijagunner
Apparantly he was one of the 26 preliminary players yeah, but Arsenal opted not to release him.
nikolaijns
We need to give up on Vela. He does have talent but shows few signs of delivering on it when he's had the chance. Not suited to English football at all, and doesn't have anything to make him stand out above the pack apart from his finishing, and even that has let him down. That said, our formation hasnt suited him these past few seasons. In a 4-4-2 he'd probably do better, but there are too many other players in front of him in the queue.
krismon1
Laurent Koscielny is the closest thing to Ricardo Carvalho I have seen in years, he has that blistering pace and positioning, a dirty side to his character and that nack of being in the right place at the irght time. next season I can see him being one o four first picks in defence if he continues to develope as he did this season. Love the raw ingrediants he has!
LondonGooner
I think we should give one more season to Vela to prove himself. If he starts showing something on the pitch then fine we can keep him. Otherwise there's plenty of suitors for him over in Spain or Italy who would love their players to learn the art of chipping from him.
Eboue=GOD
Agreed on Koscielny. He's made a few rash errors this year, but I've the impression he's a quick learner and just gets his head down and gets on with it. His anticipation is very good and I think you're right LG, he doesn't mind a bit of the rough stuff.
Little Dutch
This Is My Message To Robin fack Persie : If He Thinks that he can Cover His Bad Footballing with Bull*****s , Then He Is a Really Classy Faggot !-------- The Day's Not Over RVP ! Come to the Bridge Next Season and You'll Definitely Enjoy The Rest Of the Party ............. I'm Sure You'll Wish your mama was died before you come out of that Bitch's Belly Then
The Persian
Does anybody feel a need to reply to the above post?? I laughed my pants off at it.
Eboue=GOD
Moron alert.
Deltaforce
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Arsenal Articles

Chambers Rewarded For Early Season Form (Thursday August 28 2014)

Arsenal Keep Calm And Carry On (Thursday August 28 2014)

Giroud Has Surgery, Out For 4 Months (Wednesday August 27 2014)

Stats: Arsenal v Besiktas (Wednesday August 27 2014)

Arsenal Draw Southampton In League Cup (Wednesday August 27 2014)

Arsenal v Besiktas Match Preview (Tuesday August 26 2014)

Fifty Shades Of Arsenal Opinion (Monday August 25 2014)

Arsenal Chew Hard On Toffees (Saturday August 23 2014)

Archived Arsenal Articles

List All Vital Arsenal Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Naijagunner 94
2. Amos. 69
3. Chippy Brady 58
4. Galway Gooner 33
5. Joe_@** 29
6. Rocky7 25
7. Deltaforce 22
8. NYArse 21
9. nikolaijns 20
10. Guyfox 17

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Everton 2 - 2 Arsenal
Arsenal 2 - 1 Crystal Palace

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
2. Swansea 3 3 0 0 5 9
3. Spurs 2 2 0 0 5 6
4. Man City 3 2 0 1 3 6
5. Arsenal 2 1 1 0 1 4
6. Southampton 3 1 1 1 1 4
7. Hull City 2 1 1 0 1 4
8. Aston Villa 2 1 1 0 1 4

Breaking League News

Slip or Not, There Was Only Going To Be 1 Winner
Swansea : 30/08/2014 22:16:00
Simpson Seals Leicester Switch
Q.P.R. : 30/08/2014 22:07:00
Austin Off The Mark
Q.P.R. : 30/08/2014 21:48:00
NUFC v Crystal Palace Match Analysis
Newcastle : 30/08/2014 21:21:00
Martinez Disappointed With Defending
Everton : 30/08/2014 21:16:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Which players will we bring in before the transfer window closes on Sept 1st?
Suggested By:  
Defender 14%
Midfielder 0%
Forward 20%
More than one of these 53%
None 13%