Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

4 Things We Learned from 3rd Round Weekend

4 Things We Learned from 3rd Round Weekend

Walcott is progressing at centre forward

Whilst I still don`t believe it to be his best position, Walcott had his most convincing game yet in the central striker`s position against Spurs. Tottenham played with two nominal strikers, but Walcott showed them simply laying tactical foundations isn`t sufficient to guarantee an attacking threat. Walcott looked stronger and braver in the duels (he had to be stretchered off because he ran 40 yards to close down a Spurs player with an already injured knee) and his movement was as good as it has ever been through the centre.

Walcott has been virtually playing as a striker for the last 12 months; it`s just that his starting position is from the right, where he avoids detection, running between full backs and centre halves and allowing Giroud to occupy the centre halves. But there was evidence on Saturday evening that Walcott`s movement from the centre can occupy defences as well. He took the Spurs defence away from an unmarked Santi Cazorla for the first goal and with a good selection of creative players behind him, Walcott as a centre forward might not be the last resort it would have been viewed as at the beginning of the season.

It probably helped Theo to have an impressive Serge Gnabry to his right, whose movement with and without the ball caused Tottenham problems in the first half. Gnabry also provides a physical presence and his probing invention complimented Walcott`s running. My only concern is that Theo can be a tad selfish when playing through the middle. He sometimes eschews the pass in favour of the shot. For two of Walcott`s better chances, he arguably had a more attractive passing option. I would put that down to Walcott`s desperation to prove himself as a centre forward. Spurs play quite an open game too, which will have suited Theo. But you have to think, for the time being at least, he is ahead of Lukas Podolski in the pecking order for a central berth in Giroud`s absence.

4-4-2 is being exposed in the modern game

Both Manchester United and Tottenham Hotspur produced insipid performances bookmarked by creative struggles. The issue that both teams appeared to have was a lack of subtlety in the final third. It`s often said that playing a four man midfield will lose you the skirmish for possessive domination in midfield. Whilst there is stock in that theory, what United and Spurs found to their cost is that a prosaic 4-4-2 leaves the midfield and the forwards at too great a disconnect.

Neither side had a player willing to play between the lines of the opposition`s midfield and defence and feed their strikers. Though it`s true that Arsenal being down to ten men might have contributed to the impression, Spurs did not look even slightly threatening to Arsenal until Sherwood replaced Soldado with Chadli. Chadli was available to link the play in Arsenal`s third and, if anything, just ensure that attacks didn`t break down before they could gather any momentum. Denied a strike force of Rooney and van Persie, United struggle to make 4-4-2 work without Rooney dropping off of the front line. That Shinji Kagawa is still struggling to make an impression without the aforementioned strike force is worrying in the extreme for United.

The Japanese international ought to possess all of the attributes to mend such a weakness in United`s approach but the truth is, even Ferguson could not shoehorn him into United`s setup. Moyes has the look of a half decent geography teacher who has been promoted to Education Secretary, so perhaps it`s unrealistic to expect him to solve the problem of Kagawa any time soon. In the meantime, United desperately need a creative player to make Moyes` rather prosaic "4-42, feed the wingers and get crosses in" style.

Everybody is devaluing the F.A. Cup

Paul Lambert and Sam Allardyce were both rather blunt in their pre match assessments of the F.A. Cup. Both, perhaps poetically, suffered at the hands of Football League opposition. Villa were humbled at home to League One strugglers Sheffield United, whilst West Ham were given a humiliating 5-0 shoeing at Nottingham Forest. As a result, both managers have been criticised for banging a further nail in the coffin of the F.A. Cup.

Yet Villa only made 4 changes from their last Premier League game, one enforced due to an injury in the warm up. The worry for Sam Allardyce isn`t so much that a shadow side were utterly humped at the City Ground, it`s that his side looked so unmotivated. Despite Allardyce`s sheepish post match comments, in which he typically looked to shift the blame from himself, the Hammers were still able to field Matt Jarvis, Stewart Downing, Alou Diarra, Modibo Maiga and Ravel Morrison.

Hull City made 9 changes to their side, but largely escaped media censure because a) they won 2-0 at Middlesbrough and b) Steve Bruce was a little quieter about his intentions. Manchester United and Arsenal still made changes to their line ups despite playing Premier League opposition, but of course, they have the resources to do so. The television companies don`t help either with stupid kickoff times and the draw for the next round being conducted well before the current round has finished.

Ultimately, the F.A. Cup`s sheen will never be restored whilst more lucrative targets (Champions League qualification, Premier League survival) decide manager`s futures in football`s oak panelled boardrooms. However, you feel the scheduling of the Premier League also doesn`t help the F.A. Cup 3rd round weekend, with most sides playing 4 games in 9 days over the festive season. Christmas football is something of a tradition in England and a fine one it is too. However, I find it difficult to understand the obsession with playing on New Year`s Day. Most football fans aren`t really in any condition to enthuse over the January 1st match, the players are clearly exhausted by then and it infringes on the 3rd round, a staple weekend of the calendar. The August international friendly is soon to be confined to the past. Next season, that ought to give the Premier League an available midweek slot to relieve the New Year`s Day fixture of its arduous duties for good and alleviate the schedule, meaning managers feel more inclined to field more competitive sides.

The media`s addiction to outrage is making football soft

That there is even the slightest hint of a suggestion that Theo Walcott could face F.A. censure for reminding travelling Tottenham fans of the score is an exasperating sign o` the times. Arsene Wenger clearly became crabby with ITV`s line of questioning following his side`s consummate win over Spurs, so intent were they on working a controversial angle from a nothing incident. To accuse Walcott of "inciting" Tottenham fans is to relieve fully grown adults of their responsibility to govern their own emotions.

Even leaving aside the "they started it" argument, given the coins and vitriol Walcott received from the Spurs fans, if a man smiling and mockingly reminding you of the score causes you to lose control of your emotions then the problem is yours, not the player`s. We should not seek to pander to the emotionally incontinent in this way. As a society, we`re becoming more sensitive with each passing year. We are at a point now where people love to get offended and will seek offence in the most innocuous of incidents.

This sense of entitlement is fuelled by the media, ravenous for some kind of inflammatory angle. Hence, their language is intentionally deceptive and laden with innuendo. Thus, Walcott "aimed a gesture" at Spurs fans they say. It`s technically true that he did, but journalists are fully aware of the subconscious connotations of such conniving phraseology. The word "incitement" is weaved into paragraphs examining the incident. "Sticks and stones" is a nursery rhyme we teach children at playschool, yet it seems some fully grown men could do with a revision of that sentiment. Football has been sterilised quite enough without the need for us all to turn into delicate little flowers. LD.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Tim Stillman
Date:Monday January 6 2014
Time: 8:56AM


Theo still cannot hold up the ball as a striker, but he was much much better than last season when he played alone upfront a couple of times. I don't see a huge problem with his selfishness when shooting - his finishing has improved and for me, it's ok if he misses a few. I was despairing over Theo's intelligence a couple of seasons back, but there is only silence on that aspect now which is testament to his improvement. His improvement has been steadier over the past 2 seasons compared to Ramsey this season for eg, and hence is getting a lot less attention.
06/01/2014 09:25:00
I have noticed since his return that Theo Walcott's movement is markedly improved. His runs seem much more intelligent designed either to make space for others or to get himself through on goal. Before it seemed as though there wasn't much thought behind it all.

I have no problem with him being greedy either (unless it's something complete ridiculous like the Adebayor/Bendtner thing in the Spurs 4-4 a few years ago) we need someone willing to try and stick the ball in the back of the net. It might cost us every now and again, but I think it will be more beneficial than not. Especially as I really rate Theo as a finisher.
06/01/2014 09:38:00
Theo still has to learn some of the subtleties and nuances of the central role which as Tim indicates does include knowing when to pass and when to shoot. Having said that he is a good finisher and usually gets his shots on target so it's not an entirely bad instinct to shoot first and ask the question later. It's a matter of better judgement within fine lines. Theo's incitement of spud supporters perhaps wasn't as provocative as Adebayor's at City a couple of seasons back but there're bound to be some who draw parallels with the reaction of some of the Arsenal support on that occasion. Perhaps we are all too sensitive and should at times accept that players are entitled to give as well as receive.
06/01/2014 10:47:00
Indeed. Sat in the away end when Adebayor executed his knee slide, I can't pretend I enjoyed it or found much comedy in it, but do you know what? I managed to stop myself lobbing coins or objects at him and managed not to have a complete emotional breakdown. I;m always minded of this excellent skit from Aussie comedian Steve Hughes
Little Dutch
06/01/2014 12:51:00
It's true to say Walcott doesn't really hold the ball up and probably never will be able to, though he gave it a try. But van Persie wasn't much of a back to goal striker and neither is Suarez, they both cause havoc with their movement more than anything. It's probably a more realistic stylistic aspiration for Walcott than a Giroud or Adebayor type.
Little Dutch
06/01/2014 12:53:00
I think Theo was and still is a victim of high expectations. The pomp and pageantry that followed his early years set him up for early failure and the lingering effect is going to be there throughout his career. Still, it is gratifying to read the general acknowledgement that he is improving and has improved. For fans of a club not afraid to take on board young players we should perhaps show more than the average tolerance for growing pains even if the players in question are prodigies.
06/01/2014 13:20:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of International Football News


Recent Arsenal Articles

Instant Reactions - Arsenal v Crystal Palace (20/1/18)

Following today's clash between Arsenal and Crystal Palace, here are the instant reactions from both managers.

Stats: Arsenal v Crystal Palace

All the stats from Arsenal (4) vs (1) Crystal Palace, Emirates Stadium, 20/1/18 Att: 59,386

Arsenal v Crystal Palace - Follow On Twitter - 20-1-18

Arsenal are at the Emirates Stadium with Crystal Palace the visitors today, this will be a 3pm kick-off.

Arsenal Stars Turn The Table On Twitter Trolls

This is hilarious. Arsenal stars challenged Twitter Trolls after they criticised him on Twitter saying they could have scored better blindfolded.

Arsenal Archived Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Highbury Gooner
Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Palace MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Maitland-Niles0%
Sub - Nelson12%
Sub - Kolasinac12%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Arsenal Fixtures

Vital Football Comment