Vital Football

Latest Arsenal FC News

Arsenal V Spurs - My Verdict

Arsenal V Spurs - My Verdict

I read an intresting article on Vital Spurs a couple of days ago comparing Tottenham's squad with Arsenal's.

Although I agreed with some of what the writer said, I disagreed with some too.

So, with Spurs making plenty of noise about getting into the Champions league, I thought I'd give my own opinion on our respective starting X1's and squads.

Lehmann V Robinson. The verdict of the writer on Vital Spurs was 'Draw'. I say Lehmann. Not because I'm biased but because no 'keeper in the Premiership conceeded more than Robinson last season, Lehmann meanwhile was solid last season.

Eboue V Chimbonda Verdict of Spurs writer 'Draw.' My verdict - Chimbonda. While Eboue is a superior attacking player, Chimbonda has more experience than Eboue and looks more solid at the back.

Clichy V Bale. The verdict on Vital Spurs - Bale. My verdict - Clichy. Clichy was under a huge ammount of pressure last season to replace the best left back in the world (Ashley Cole), and he did it with ease. Bale was impressive last season but he was impressive in the Championship. He has to do a lot before he can be considered better than Clichy.

Toure V King. Vital Spurs verdict - draw. My verdict - Toure. kolo has emmerged as one of the best defenders in the world, his reading of the game is second to none, nor is his power, drive or leadership.

Gallas V Dawson. Vital Spurs verdict - Gallas (just). My Verdict - Gallas by a country mile. Dawson is a great young prospect but Gallas has proven himself at every level and in the biggest of games. Dawson has a bright future, but the difference in quality is impossible to measure.

Hleb V Lennon. Vital Spurs verdict - Lennon. My verdict - draw. Lennon is great when he's running at players, he can go past mot men as easily as Lampard can eat a box of pies, however, he lacks an end product. If he was to improve his crossing and finishing he could easily be one of the best wingers in Europe. Hleb is a fantastic player who can run through teams all day. However, he needs to find his shooting boots. He's always looking to pass the ball, even when he's in a great shooting position.

Van Persie V Malbranque. Vital spurs verdict - Van Persie. I wouln't compare these two players, Van Persie is a striker who can play on the wing, not a winger who can play up top. I would compare Rosicky and Malbranque. Verdict - Rosicky. The tenacious Czech captain is a far superior player in every aspect. He's better going forward and gets back to support his full back more.

Gilberto V Zakora. Vital Spurs verdict - Zakora. My verdict - Gilberto. Bert proved himself to be one of the best holding mifielders around last season. He made a fantastic captain in the absence of Henry and scored some crucial goals for us last season.

Fabregas V Jenas. Vital Spurs verict - Fabregas. My verict - Cesc. The 'ickle Spainard has gone from being a talented yongster to being a world-class leader and playmaker. Still only 20, he has one hell of a future ahead of him.

Da Silva V Berbatov. Vital Spurs - Berbatov. My verdict - Berbatov. While Da Silva's scoring record was outstanding in Croatia, he hasn't played at Premiership level yet. I'm sure he'll be a hit but Berbatov proved a class act last season.

Van Persie V Bent. Vital Spurs didn't compare them. My verdict - Van Pesie. The young Dutchman proved last season that he is a top striker. His 13 goals by January proved that.


Almunia V Cerny. Vital Spurs - draw. My verdict - draw. Both average players.

Senderos V Kaboul. Vital Spurs - draw. My verdict - Senderos. Kaboul comes with quite a reputation, but Senderos has proved he has quality, if not on a regular basis.

Walcott V Tarrabt. Vital Spurs verdict - draw. My verdict - Walcott. Theo has proved he has what it takes to play in the Premiership, rescuing Arsenal on several occasions last season. Tarrabt only made 2 (I think) sub appearances last season, and while he showed some promise, he has to do more before he can be treated as Walcott's equal.

Adebayor V Defoe. Vital Spurs - Defore. My verdict - Adebayor. Defoe is a talented player but he is just a shadow of the player that led Spurs' attacking line a few years ago. Adebayor is a constant threat with his finishing (not great, but always improving) and his physical presence on the pitch.

Keane V Bendtner. Vital spurs didn't compare them. My verdict - Keane. Bendtner hasn't played a Premiership game yet, while Keane has proved over the last few years that he is a good player.

There you have it. My honest opinions.

Any thoughts?

Writer:Nick Simmonett
Date:Tuesday July 10 2007
Time: 3:47PM


I'm ready for some stick from our neighbours....
10/07/2007 15:50:00
nice and clean simmy. any neutral would agree with these
10/07/2007 15:56:00
I have carefully considered your appraisals simmo and having done so the real fault I can find is that the Eboue v Chimbonda is not in bold. Though I would also say that Hleb and Lennon are entirely different players and direct comparisons may not be relevant but I would still plump for Hleb as the more accomplished.
10/07/2007 15:56:00
Not really - 1) Robinson v Lehmann is a draw. Robbo can play much better and will be behind a better defence. Jens will not be able to raise his game further. 2)I think the Dawson & King v Gallas & Toure comes out as a draw. Gallas was poor last season, Dawson is better than he is given credit for 3) You have a superior midfield and win that position 3-1 4) Up front, Berbatov should be measured with RvP as they are creators as well as scorers and Bent should be considered v DaSilva. Berbs beats RvP because there is still the feeling that RvP has temperament issues, Bent v DaSilva is a draw as Bent has done it in the Prem but DaSilva has the better Int record. On the subs bench Kaboul v Senderos is a draw as Senderos is ponderous and probably only got picked for the Swiss as they such a small pool.
10/07/2007 16:02:00
Keep Dreaming Girls!!
10/07/2007 16:05:00
Desperation, Has Van Rapist got a twin we don`t know about?????????
10/07/2007 16:06:00
You obviously cant read in relation to Van Persie Cock-eril. You really are thick.
10/07/2007 16:13:00
I havent seen the Spuds article but it looks like they only think they have 4/5 better players than us? If so why do the majority of them think they will now take 4th when we have better cover and a better manager?
10/07/2007 16:16:00
ICE-Wipe10 We have 11 Berbatov`s. Same old Arse allways cheating!!!
10/07/2007 16:18:00
Thats a cheat,especially the TW part lol the kid was at the WC ffs
10/07/2007 16:19:00
Page 1/14
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14

Login to post a comment

Recent Arsenal Articles

Wembley No Longer A Short Affair For Arsenal

Following a u-turn from the EFL, Arsenal have now been given permission to wear our traditional red shirts and white shorts at Wembley in the EFL Cup Final against Manchester City...

Five Year Emirates Extension For Arsenal

Arsenal confirmed yesterday that a new five year extension with Emirates had been agreed.

Leicester City Clash Postponed

Owing to Leicester City's continued involvement in the FA Cup this season, our game against them in March has been postponed and requires a new date.

Lacezette Still A Month Away From A Return

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Arsenal FC and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

Arsenal Archived Articles

Vital Arsenal articles from

Site Journalists

Highbury Gooner
Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

EL - Ostersunds MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Kolasinac0%
Sub - Nketiah0%
Sub - Nelson0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Arsenal Results (view all)

Arsenal Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Galway Gooner2
The Vital Football Members League